The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jprspereira]

Top Trade: your red malk dragon is worth 3-4 MA and your Malk elemental cat is worth 1 MA. Their store corgi is worth 1.5 MA and the Malk wolf is just a regular old rare (albeit might have *slightly* higher value based on demand, but not enough to add much on this trade). this trade is unfair to you

Bottom Trade: their dinosaur stores are 1 MA each and the butterfly wolves are 1 old rare each so their side totals 3.2 MA. your side is the malk dragon (3-4 MA, flying dog store pets (.5 MA each so 2 MA for all four), and the dark GSD (1 MA since it’s a TD) so your side totals 6-7 MA. your side is also much better demand wise with the Malk Dragon alone. This trade is unfair to you

tysm, can you link me to where that dragon is on the list?
im not seeing it ;~; so im not synthesizing its worth as 3-4 ma

They gave you incorrect information. The Red Malk Dragon is indeed 3 to 4MA but this one is called Copper Dragon, not Red Malk Dragon. The way to distinguish is that yours (Copper Dragon) is a very rare, and red malk dragon is a omgsr

Copper Dragon is 0.5MA.

[jprspereira]

is this fair?

Mountain Lion PPS can often get overpay but its value on Horror's is 0.5MA. Your side is worth 1 to 1.5MA.

[Cloud-puffsrule4ever]

is this fair?

Mountain Lion PPS can often get overpay but its value on Horror's is 0.5MA. Your side is worth 1 to 1.5MA.

I agree, a 2013 OMGSR is not worth that. I say you could get more/lower your end.😁

[beignet]

Top Trade: your red malk dragon is worth 3-4 MA and your Malk elemental cat is worth 1 MA. Their store corgi is worth 1.5 MA and the Malk wolf is just a regular old rare (albeit might have *slightly* higher value based on demand, but not enough to add much on this trade). this trade is unfair to you

Bottom Trade: their dinosaur stores are 1 MA each and the butterfly wolves are 1 old rare each so their side totals 3.2 MA. your side is the malk dragon (3-4 MA, flying dog store pets (.5 MA each so 2 MA for all four), and the dark GSD (1 MA since it’s a TD) so your side totals 6-7 MA. your side is also much better demand wise with the Malk Dragon alone. This trade is unfair to you

tysm, can you link me to where that dragon is on the list?
im not seeing it ;~; so im not synthesizing its worth as 3-4 ma

they have the wrong dragon in mind- your dragon is the copper malk dragon, which often gets around 0.5 ma. :]

appreciate the clarification, i thought that might be the issue but i couldn't remember the name.

can i ask for some second opinions in that case?

thoughts on this?
and this demand-wise?

[MrAnkle]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=114028056&userid=986678&signature=Z8P2qOpNed5yTfG2dNtsew

i definitely would like the pets on their side, but i don't know if this is overpay! :,)

[A.ntique]

They gave you incorrect information. The Red Malk Dragon is indeed 3 to 4MA but this one is called Copper Dragon, not Red Malk Dragon. The way to distinguish is that yours (Copper Dragon) is a very rare, and red malk dragon is a omgsr

Copper Dragon is 0.5MA.

Thank you for the correction! I wasn’t aware of the copper malk dragon and thought they were the same!

[A.ntique]

I am looking to date swap some staff dogs from ‘09, is this a fair addition being asked on my part? I am not sure what the rule of thumb is for this litter

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114028277&userid=693297&signature=UQVrJpsGIBqc_OBN8V_dZw

[reefspeef]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114028634&userid=837967&signature=lR8aPpjBQNNKGpu83xn9lw
thoughts on this? thx!!

[jaxonlynx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114028634&userid=837967&signature=lR8aPpjBQNNKGpu83xn9lw
thoughts on this? thx!!

• the side of pets that they want is a bit more valuable than the ones they're offering with.
> i'd say their side should have the 2014 very uncommon butterfly wolf, 2014 extremely uncommon fox, one of the four very uncommon 2014 pets, the 2016 uncommon bat, and all three 2017 very common pets.
> your side should have the 2013 very uncommon malk dog, the 2013 extremely uncommon cat, the very uncommon 2012 dog, the 2019 uncommon dog, and the 2022 common dog.
• the 2011 and extremely uncommon gap won't equal to the commons and uncommons they offered in my opinion. you can get a better offer with pets closer to that year and extremely uncommon rarity.
• and no, i am not taking species nor looks into consideration because, usually that doesn't matter to me personally but, i know some people do care so, just keep in mind of that!

[Cartier]

Thoughts?
Im not sure what is fair. Thank you