The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jaxonlynx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114025089&userid=837967&signature=Z6g1XaydxdQ9leHu8VhiqQ
thoughts? thanks!

• the 2015 rare is worth the same as one of the two 2017 rares.
• so, keep one of the rares and remove the rest of the pets or keep both very uncommon pets and remove the rares that they want.
aka:
• option 1:
for or (not both!)

option 2:
for and

[Rhodophobia]

Ty for all the help guys! Have a lovely day ^^

[bruisedfruit]

Should I accept this? I’m super tempted

[beignet]

thoughts on this?
and this demand-wise?

[A.ntique]

thoughts on this?
and this demand-wise?

Top Trade: your red malk dragon is worth 3-4 MA and your Malk elemental cat is worth 1 MA. Their store corgi is worth 1.5 MA and the Malk wolf is just a regular old rare (albeit might have *slightly* higher value based on demand, but not enough to add much on this trade). this trade is unfair to you

Bottom Trade: their dinosaur stores are 1 MA each and the butterfly wolves are 1 old rare each so their side totals 3.2 MA. your side is the malk dragon (3-4 MA, flying dog store pets (.5 MA each so 2 MA for all four), and the dark GSD (1 MA since it’s a TD) so your side totals 6-7 MA. your side is also much better demand wise with the Malk Dragon alone. This trade is unfair to you

[A.ntique]

Should I accept this? I’m super tempted

Their side: 1.5 Nons (RR)
Your side: Warriors (4.5 MA I believe), Cheshire Cat (.5 N/5 MA), 2012 Store (1 MA), Kitsune (3-4 MA), 2013 store (1 MA), unicorn stores (1 MA total), santa hat dog (1.5 MA), Christmas tree dog (1 MA) = 1.7-1.8 N.

I believe you could remove 2-3 MA from your side to make it even. I did this on mobile so please feel free to check my work on this, someone ^^

[jprspereira]

Should I accept this? I’m super tempted

Their side: 1.5 Nons (RR)
Your side: Warriors (4.5 MA I believe), Cheshire Cat (.5 N/5 MA), 2012 Store (1 MA), Kitsune (3-4 MA), 2013 store (1 MA), unicorn stores (1 MA total), santa hat dog (1.5 MA), Christmas tree dog (1 MA) = 1.7-1.8 N.

I believe you could remove 2-3 MA from your side to make it even. I did this on mobile so please feel free to check my work on this, someone ^^

Their side is 2.15n to 2.25, so they need to remove 6.5-7.5MA to make it fair.

[beignet]

thoughts on this?
and this demand-wise?

Top Trade: your red malk dragon is worth 3-4 MA and your Malk elemental cat is worth 1 MA. Their store corgi is worth 1.5 MA and the Malk wolf is just a regular old rare (albeit might have *slightly* higher value based on demand, but not enough to add much on this trade). this trade is unfair to you

Bottom Trade: their dinosaur stores are 1 MA each and the butterfly wolves are 1 old rare each so their side totals 3.2 MA. your side is the malk dragon (3-4 MA, flying dog store pets (.5 MA each so 2 MA for all four), and the dark GSD (1 MA since it’s a TD) so your side totals 6-7 MA. your side is also much better demand wise with the Malk Dragon alone. This trade is unfair to you

tysm, can you link me to where that dragon is on the list?
im not seeing it ;~; so im not synthesizing its worth as 3-4 ma

[eleutheromaniac.]

is this fair?

[puffy]

Top Trade: your red malk dragon is worth 3-4 MA and your Malk elemental cat is worth 1 MA. Their store corgi is worth 1.5 MA and the Malk wolf is just a regular old rare (albeit might have *slightly* higher value based on demand, but not enough to add much on this trade). this trade is unfair to you

Bottom Trade: their dinosaur stores are 1 MA each and the butterfly wolves are 1 old rare each so their side totals 3.2 MA. your side is the malk dragon (3-4 MA, flying dog store pets (.5 MA each so 2 MA for all four), and the dark GSD (1 MA since it’s a TD) so your side totals 6-7 MA. your side is also much better demand wise with the Malk Dragon alone. This trade is unfair to you

tysm, can you link me to where that dragon is on the list?
im not seeing it ;~; so im not synthesizing its worth as 3-4 ma

they have the wrong dragon in mind- your dragon is the copper malk dragon, which often gets around 0.5 ma. :]