The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[honeycrisq]

Hello! Is this fair? I have my doubts but I recently returned to the site and am still trying to readapt to the new rarity system and C$ values.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=113991192&userid=698437&signature=W8UpEEfqJ-i6HETdtXb9UQ

• the C$ value of those pets ranges from 177-236C$ all together. it is not fair in terms of price range because it's under the minimum worth for all of those pets.
• i used horror's pricing chart to value them!

This is what I suspected, but I wanted to make sure I got a second opinion before I jumped to conclusions. Thanks so much! <3

[polyphon]

is this fair? thanks for any help!

[lady gaga]

hows this?

[Mothmanofficial]

Guys what do we think of this trade? Specifically looking at demand because I don't see too many trades for the two pets on their side.

[texastoast]

Guys what do we think of this trade? Specifically looking at demand because I don't see too many trades for the two pets on their side.

fair swap, 10 old rares are on both sides c$ wise its also fair, but the dog may fetch another rare due to being a truedate. Just depends on which you'd prefer.

hows this?

overpay on the c$ side, your pet is worth about 100 c$

[choerry]

opinions on this trade? not rly sure about worths of storepets now,,

[texastoast]

opinions on this trade? not rly sure about worths of storepets now,,

rare pets wise, it's unfair to the bottom. The bottom side is worth 8 old rares, while the top is only worth 6. c$ wise, its about fair. Just depends on whether you're trading for pets or c$.

[honeycrisq]

Thoughts?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=113992329&userid=698437&signature=h65Dv2S5CyA0vsr6e4unwg

[Oopsiedaisies]

Hey, I need some help with this one, thanks!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=113992787&userid=918499&signature=grwTvD1Dt5GYU9DBXqQcsQ

[jaxonlynx]

Hey, I need some help with this one, thanks!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=113992787&userid=918499&signature=grwTvD1Dt5GYU9DBXqQcsQ

• their offer with the spider and 5C$ is only worth 30-40C$ in value while yours is 50-80C$ in value
• remove at least 5 of the 2023 pets to make it fair.
• the spider has no special demand and is normally valued at 25-35C$
• the 2024 rares are all 5-8C$ each, so, since there are 10 of them, that makes them worth 50-80C$ together.
• by removing 5 of the 2023 rare pets, the value would go to 25-40C$