The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread / NEW THREAD

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110961224&userid=861858&signature=BnGpDR0v4jDOdOYrwI8c1A

Hi! Is this a fair trade? Because I feel like something's off

Technically they overpay with that cat as your side is 4 old rares and theirs would be 5. However in this case I feel like selling 4 store pets separately would be way easier than this particular warrior ^^

[Wysterinka]

Is this fair? And if not, what kind of years and rarities would be fair for the 2009 BW?

View Trade Here

Any help at all appreciated, thank you in advance!

Your bw is 2.5 old rares and so is their side without the vr bat. So I'd say the bat is overpay.

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110852898&userid=933740&signature=RrVFmsPgqLbja0B_BcC4Hw

how fair is this? the kirin is my dreamie!!

I don’t think this is fair for you, especially the age of your pets i think even one would be slightly unfair but of course if it’s a dreamy you may do as you wish, but I’d honestly be offering only one if any of those pets

I disagree with the statement that any one of the pets would be fair,

The Kirin is valued at 2 nons,
Your phoenix is a true date I believe so that would also fetch a solid 2 nons as opposed to the shaky 1.5-2 non demand of the phoenix.

So I would say the phoenix is a fair swap for the kirin ❤️

I for one think this seems fair actually 😆 I see more people trying to trade for the kirins than the phoenix. I traded 2 or 3 of those before and never got 2 nons for the kirin, always 2.5n (besides 2021 is also TD I think).
So while TD phoenix seems nice and could maybe get more than usual, I wouldn't have issue with this trade as much. But you can perhaps try to swap just the kirin for phoenix? Although it's good offer in my eyes ^^ Phoenix value seem wonky to me because way more people want a cool designed horse than a fire chicken xD

[screamingrainfrog]

Hello! Can I get an opinion on this?
I have no idea how much the rat is worth or what it trades for
Thank you in advance :)

[Happily Wrathful]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110985555&userid=730104&signature=sBErmPMD9IBlZNGm0Asoow

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110955890&userid=730104&signature=lmsmdTz_xVH1Moo3FoYg1Q
hello im not entirely sure if this would be the right thread for this but can you tell me which one of these trades is worth more?

[riftintime]

is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110962420&userid=714454&signature=OnwYiOUALX5JfdyZh-a2MQ

[Milu]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110981894&userid=154247&signature=KWnm5ldw15aprsG3CsyzCQ

I got edit, I think is good? I'm not robbing anyone?

still needing help w this thank u 🥹
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110981894&userid=154247&signature=KWnm5ldw15aprsG3CsyzCQ

[Audrey_Bee]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110981894&userid=154247&signature=KWnm5ldw15aprsG3CsyzCQ

I got edit, I think is good? I'm not robbing anyone?

still needing help w this thank u 🥹
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110981894&userid=154247&signature=KWnm5ldw15aprsG3CsyzCQ

Hi!
So value wise you would be overpaying quite a bit as they have recent rares and your store pets are worth an old rare each so your side adds up to quite a bit.

The malk fae foxes to retch overpay, though I wouldn't put them anything over an old rare so I'd say you're still probably overpaying even taking demand into account ❤️

[chloe1122aa]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110969600&userid=793906&signature=esnFmjy8o4WzT4nJ9JjhCg

BEGGING FOR HELP, i don’t know my items well atall, is this fair to me?

[TheQueensToast]

Are the pets in this group worth 158C$ in total?

accounts/viewgroup.php?groupid=8204855&userid=1033269

Feel free to skip over this, but here's the thinking on the price!!

2010 VR lion - 40
2010 rare rat - 20
2023 EUC - 3C$
2022 VC - 2C$
2022 rare - 5C$
2022 rare - 5C$
2022 VUC - 2C$
2020 VUC - 2C$
2015 EUC - 7C$
2015 UC - 3C$
2014 VUC - 5C$
2014 VUC - 5C$
2014 VUC - 5C$
2011 rare - 25C$
2010 rare- 27C$
All the commons and below - 2C$

This all comes out to a total of 158


Tysm in advance!!

Sill looking for an opinion!!