The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread / NEW THREAD

[Audrey_Bee]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110976852&userid=880031&signature=ldPuNglTKBAXJkJK-53fzg

Help! Much appreciated

Your tess horse is worth 2MA (20 old rares) and they're offering a small fraction of that, very unfair to you

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110927003&userid=21128&signature=HGYqw6h5N9p3wx_edfi0jw

Help appreciated! I am unsure of the value of a couple of these since they are older and rare/very rare. Thanks in advance!!

They would be underpaying. Usually in c$ price, .5MA pets are valued 150-200c$ but 5 old rare pets separately would be always closer to 200 if you value each at 40c$. The rest of lower rarity pets on your side would also be free.

[Audrey_Bee]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110927003&userid=21128&signature=HGYqw6h5N9p3wx_edfi0jw

Help appreciated! I am unsure of the value of a couple of these since they are older and rare/very rare. Thanks in advance!!

They would be underpaying. Usually in c$ price, .5MA pets are valued 150-200c$ but 5 old rare pets separately would be always closer to 200 if you value each at 40c$. The rest of lower rarity pets on your side would also be free.

I'm unsure on where you're getting the values from, if you don't mind me saying!
Using horrors guide, my maths is correct in saying their side is worth 100-150 🤔

[Supreme]

Can anyone help me on this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110972721&userid=702384&signature=pNZeEjiNPvn2ut8ErK5zbQ

[Wysterinka]

Also; I actually came here to ask about a trade of my own. 😂😂 trades/viewtrade.php?id=110961620&userid=115676&signature=00r0_uxa-TzY7qm8s5uVGg

I know the warriors seem to have good demand; I was wondering if the red stripe is easily traded? I'm looking to trade up my fodder but as stated I'm still learning what all is worth what and trying to keep up with demand is wild. Idk how some of y'all do it. 😂

Any input is appreciated!

Your warrior cats will definitely have more demand than this dog. The whole litter isn't too popular so only collectors who still need it might want it. However it being rr from 2019 will also decrease the amount of people who would be interested since most will want a TD one, like your warrior cats. Besides they grow in demand and value lately too ^^

[Audrey_Bee]

:D

Can anyone help me on this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110972721&userid=702384&signature=pNZeEjiNPvn2ut8ErK5zbQ

The bwolf has a fave value of 1MA (10 old rares).
You side has just over 4 old rares so they're overpaying.

Do note that I'm unable to find data on hiw much the bwolf actively trades for. But it is valued on the list at 1MA

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110927003&userid=21128&signature=HGYqw6h5N9p3wx_edfi0jw

Help appreciated! I am unsure of the value of a couple of these since they are older and rare/very rare. Thanks in advance!!

They would be underpaying. Usually in c$ price, .5MA pets are valued 150-200c$ but 5 old rare pets separately would be always closer to 200 if you value each at 40c$. The rest of lower rarity pets on your side would also be free.

I'm unsure on where you're getting the values from, if you don't mind me saying!
Using horrors guide, my maths is correct in saying their side is worth 100-150 🤔

Oh it was one of the re-revised c$ guides from when there was poll about it, before ine of them was taken up for Horror'slist. Can't remember what user was it from originally, I've mostly sold 2010 rares at 40c$ ever since so the math was 5x40 😆 ofc if they value them as bulk since those are horses it would be 150 together as low .5MA and would be under either way due to the other pets.

[Wysterinka]

:D

Can anyone help me on this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110972721&userid=702384&signature=pNZeEjiNPvn2ut8ErK5zbQ

The bwolf has a fave value of 1MA (10 old rares).
You side has just over 4 old rares so they're overpaying.

Do note that I'm unable to find data on hiw much the bwolf actively trades for. But it is valued on the list at 1MA

I agree, I traded few of those at 1MA or 1.5MA as TD but I never thought of posting the data for them sadly since there was too many trades xD

[Wintersham]

Can I get help on this one please?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110978041&userid=450377&signature=QJ1y5ody67sjHVRYKwUB8A

[Declawed Wildcat]

Would anyone be able to give a second opinion on this one? Haven't really done any bigger trades since the rarity changes, not sure what would be fair for this Nick.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110978553&userid=55319&signature=gtgEtalAUeajtg88udVs8g