The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread / NEW THREAD

[~Arerona~]

Is this fair?

I'm not really sure of the Animal eggs value anymore

Thanks in advance

[luvarien]

hello! i'd ilke a second opinion; is this trade fair? i'm aware that a lot of the rares they want from me are lower demand pets, but i'm unsure if the quantity of them makes up for it or if the amount tips it over into being unfair - any help is much appreciated! <3

[Vanendra]

Is this fair? And if not, what kind of years and rarities would be fair for the 2009 BW?

View Trade Here

[piepinkpony]

I'm still rusty when it comes to old vs new rares so is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=110961818&userid=350191&signature=qI3bx4mnU3GRp0XlDHgr6g

TIA

[chloe1122aa]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110962368&userid=793906&signature=NarB9-DcN52RonD1en_8eQ

Pls pls help me, I’m not sure if this Nick pet is special I’ve had it for years, is this fair to me? Or is my pet worth more?

[riftintime]

is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110962420&userid=714454&signature=OnwYiOUALX5JfdyZh-a2MQ

[chloe1122aa]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110962560&userid=793906&signature=RK6PfQxQmyXMD_YgmijJnA

Is this fair to me?

[angst]

I'm still rusty when it comes to old vs new rares so is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=110961818&userid=350191&signature=qI3bx4mnU3GRp0XlDHgr6g

TIA

This looked unfair to the top - their rare is from 2012 and even using the new 3 year gap rule, that's 2015, and then 2018 etc. neither of the newer rares are fair here. A one on one swap from a rare of the same year or at least within 3 years (2011, 2013) would've maybe been a better offer!

Sooo many people are rusty haha, you're definitely not alone in that. And the rules keep changing! Hard to keep up 💕

[BeanCat]

Is this fair?

I'm not really sure of the Animal eggs value anymore

Thanks in advance

Not fair at all, I don’t know exact values but usually people say the date of an item is equivalent to the same dated pet but EUC-R depending on its value, some of those eggs are from 2010 etc so it’s definitely not fair to you.

[Wookieinmashoo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110903437&userid=245926&signature=cNwdvVWqjbp3cj9dYmseVg

Hello, could someone tell me what the pet side adds up to? Including the true dates for the malk and 08' dogs since I think they may be a little more.