The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[TsuginoHaru]

Would appreciate help with this, I'm not good at knowing with these types of trades ^^'
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110559490&userid=1077389&signature=yW7O4OfyDwkgCX0LM72_HA

I'm not great with item rarities but just based on pets I would consider that to be underpay on the side with more pets, the 2015 common is more like a recent UC I think but the 2015 EUC should get at least a couple 2015-ish UCs/VUCs too (please correct me if I'm wrong more experienced traders lol)

Thank you for your input! I was thinking too that it's underpay, but the amount of pets confused me, so this helps ^^

[TenMillionFireflies]

Is this fair? (Current event pet)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110551019&userid=1073239&signature=M6EoaF8kAABjIAIYbdZ8SQ
Thanks to anyone who helps!

[kth]

Pretty please can I have opinions on this trade for this 09 sitting cat?



Thanks

Bumping this, still needing opinions, haven’t received one yet and want to make sure it is fair for me and the trade partner.

[~Bai~]

Is this fair? I would really appreciate any help, thanks!

[Jacki277]

How do you think about this trade:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110541024&userid=202481&signature=49uLg0EtbFmLoz-vlTSBkg

[Audrey_Bee]

Is this fair? I would really appreciate any help, thanks!

I would say its very unfair to your items. The valentines gloves are from 2012, as its an even, they would be valued at around a 2012 rare, possibly vary rare but I tend to keep it at rare because of demand. A 2012 rare is worth 18-22 C$ alone so they're underpaying by quite a lot ❤️

[Audrey_Bee]

Is this fair? (Current event pet)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110551019&userid=1073239&signature=M6EoaF8kAABjIAIYbdZ8SQ
Thanks to anyone who helps!

If you follow the 2:1 rule it would be fair, but event pets usually turn out to be rare (not guaranteed) so if it does become rare, most people prefer not to trade rares for uncommons. But that's a preference and using the 2:1 rule even if it became rare they'd still technically be overpaying because of the dates:)

[Safrapoe]

Got an offer for my duplicate animal egg 117
No clue what those go for, but this feel very generous. HELP???
Link to trade

[liljaybird]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110587715&userid=832107&signature=TbQWmr-3XxPz1y7PNycCrA

Hi everyone!! So sorry to bother you all! Not sure if I should go for this? (I'm really bad with my rarities!) I have got one opinion saying to go for it, but they advised for another opinion! Would you say that this is fair? Thank you!

[Audrey_Bee]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110587715&userid=832107&signature=TbQWmr-3XxPz1y7PNycCrA

Hi everyone!! So sorry to bother you all! Not sure if I should go for this? (I'm really bad with my rarities!) I have got one opinion saying to go for it, but they advised for another opinion! Would you say that this is fair? Thank you!

I'd say unfair to you, I counted 40 old rares before even getting to the gryphon store pets. I believe the cake dogs are 2MA? 3MA tops and 40 is 4MA, eyeballing the rest I say your side is worth about 50 old rares at least which is 0.5 non aka 5MAso yeah...unfair to you!