The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[answrs]

looking for some help on some more expensive leaning trades please. (store and older rares, not lists)

Koi/goldfish store for newer stores

09 malks for quantity (I am only looking for the 2017 pets and later, the older pets would go straight back into trade fodder if that makes a difference)

mostly asking if the rare swaps are about the same in terms of trading interest?

deeply appreciate any insight ^^

[Marceline Abadeer]

looking for some help on some more expensive leaning trades please. (store and older rares, not lists)

Koi/goldfish store for newer stores

09 malks for quantity (I am only looking for the 2017 pets and later, the older pets would go straight back into trade fodder if that makes a difference)

mostly asking if the rare swaps are about the same in terms of trading interest?

deeply appreciate any insight ^^

The first trade is a pretty big overpay on their side since the 2014 koidogs go for .5-1 ma (leaning more towards 1)

[ZeroDiablo]

Still seeking help, thank you

Just wondering if I could get some input on this trade I just got, thank you

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108502479&userid=214650&signature=nTMaMEyQ2vlgh9glGKY5PA

[Soloee]

Bumping this

Is this a fair trade? It's a suggestion from them, so idk if it's actually not fair at all and I'm supposed to make a more fair suggestion back, or if it is pretty fair. (I usually just do monthly swap trades)

[Shippe]

Is this a fair trade? I found that both pets are worth .25-5 nons but I wanted to check, as the rat is an omgsr and the cheshire cat an er. But I know rats have poor demand, so demand-wise is it fair to the other user?

[lurkie]

i got sent this and im not sure,, is any side overpaying? thank you so much lovely chicken smoothie residents

edit: and this please >.< clickie

♡

[fuzzy350]

I'm not very good at items values, can someone tell me if this is fair to both of us?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108505632&userid=962043&signature=ESqffkQ8175sH59Pk9rW3w

[S0undH0und]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108516316&userid=1027648&signature=1AFfnBxz4kW-RYsCdkkJJg

Little help on this one please? thank you

[Get-a-Huhn]

Hey everyone,

could someone possibly tell me if this is fair? <3 Thank you so much!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108511734&userid=197971&signature=jfvzG0G5JKXbE2KDfDn-6w

[Synapsid]

Could I get some opinion(s) on this please?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108513011&userid=526141&signature=MpMA9cH_OiYsBpI2MFUHKQ