The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[- Alice -]

I am 99.9% sure this is unfair to me but can I just get an opinion real quick?; doot

[leachface]

I am 99.9% sure this is unfair to me but can I just get an opinion real quick?; doot

All I’m certain is I can recall people auctioning Pocky items about a year or so back. And they can go for older rares.
Items I believe do not get re-released, minus the items that remain indefinitely in store.
I’d personally say unfair to you, but make sure to get a second opinion

[StarryWish.]

I am 99.9% sure this is unfair to me but can I just get an opinion real quick?; doot

All I’m certain is I can recall people auctioning Pocky items about a year or so back. And they can go for older rares.
Items I believe do not get re-released, minus the items that remain indefinitely in store.
I’d personally say unfair to you, but make sure to get a second opinion

i second this, it is unfair to the poster. the pocky* alone can fetch some good pets in demand

[CristalStar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108137318&userid=983838&signature=XoQD6MWh-esNxVzLggBEcA
is this fair?

[Lee-Sins]

I am 99.9% sure this is unfair to me but can I just get an opinion real quick?; doot

All I’m certain is I can recall people auctioning Pocky items about a year or so back. And they can go for older rares.
Items I believe do not get re-released, minus the items that remain indefinitely in store.
I’d personally say unfair to you, but make sure to get a second opinion

i second this, it is unfair to the poster. the picky alone can fetch some good pets in demand

pocky item is a low to mid advent tier by itself.

[Mysteria<3]

Sooo, I think she worth a bit more… I was wondering if this is fair, or how much uncommon in other rarities are worth?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108137684&userid=603928&signature=zlL5emqrU3mptjSjUMpjGQ

Edit, my phone is being weird and won’t let me switch between groups unless I do some kind of action like add or remove a pet or switch pages in the stater page… so stuck and can’t edit even if I wanted to.

[Heather Ale]

Sooo, I think she worth a bit more… I was wondering if this is fair, or how much uncommon in other rarities are worth?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108137684&userid=603928&signature=zlL5emqrU3mptjSjUMpjGQ

Edit, my phone is being weird and won’t let me switch between groups unless I do some kind of action like add or remove a pet or switch pages in the stater page… so stuck and can’t edit even if I wanted to.

I am not proficient in trading, but I’d say unfair to you. Personally I would trade with them if their pets were from 2020 with these rarities. For a 2019 unc I’d want two more ‘23 commons on their side.

[NotHereAnymore]

I'm doing an Auction that ends today & I'd love help on what each trade is worth... The auction is for a TD Yellowfang. Thank you in advance for the help!!!

Yellowfang Auction
* Bid #1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107553502&userid=1064234&signature=6qWuC5Ri8cZrL_y7_hvaWQ

* Bid #2
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107946882&userid=1064234&signature=gX7IpAedQeQOnSi2Kw6uTA

* Bid #3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108129056&userid=1064234&signature=PhMyfMLwmgiDqZf_iCAE-A

[Mysteria<3]

I'm doing an Auction that ends today & I'd love help on what each trade is worth... The auction is for a TD Yellowfang. Thank you in advance for the help!!!

Yellowfang Auction
* Bid #1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107553502&userid=1064234&signature=6qWuC5Ri8cZrL_y7_hvaWQ

* Bid #2
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107946882&userid=1064234&signature=gX7IpAedQeQOnSi2Kw6uTA

* Bid #3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108129056&userid=1064234&signature=PhMyfMLwmgiDqZf_iCAE-A

Honesty first… I’m not the best at the numbers side of things when it comes rarities and their worth… However I think 3 is the best, it seems evened out. Then again, it’s also which pets,styles are you drawn to the most.

[Raniah]

Hello, does anyone know if these trades are fair?
Trade 1
Trade 2

Any help would be appreciated, thank you in advance.