The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[heartfades]

hi guys-

not necessarily asking if this is fair because we are just trying to work out value at the moment but i'm not too sure how to value the second side with the demand disparity if im trading these pets for rats? I know how to break it down generally but im also not too sure about the rest of the (not malk) 09 staff pets.

I know its a LOT of pets but if someone give a general/estimated value to the staff pets side id be so grateful

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108034002&userid=158024&signature=qbWwlkI2_0fvirnaLLKgAQ

I know this is a big ask but any guidance would be so appreciated c:

I did just get some input on this and thank you!! just wanted to ask if anyone could give an estimated value of the staff pets side? I know thats a big ask but I have no idea how to value the staff and (non-malk) store pets past that theyre worth a lot..

[goofer goblin]

not good with c$ trades so any help appreciated thank you !

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107715381&userid=686966&signature=O8ILwZ0S7UA-1FFaVX3eVA

[Heather Ale]

Need more item trade help
I’m happy about the offer, but I have no idea about what items go for. Opinions?

Anyone? 🥹

[Damocles]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108105640&userid=346461&signature=BPcb3ojy4C4Q0b6qfViJ-A

What is the fairness of this considering worth/value and popularity?
Thanks!!

[heartfades]

not good with c$ trades so any help appreciated thank you !

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107715381&userid=686966&signature=O8ILwZ0S7UA-1FFaVX3eVA

if youre using this revised chart 2012 R = c$28, 2012 VU = c$6, 2014 VU = c$5 which would total c$39

[Ruruskadoo]

Are any of these trades fair? I keep getting sent more trades as I'm still waiting and trying to get the earlier ones evaluated :')

This first one in particular I've been trying to get some advice on for 2 days now:
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=107976378&userid=119355&signature=Slr6rK0Gz8HMEKs3Lk3TJQ

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=108052692&userid=119355&signature=olWfaZcMyc4_vEm00-vdDQ

3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=108065505&userid=119355&signature=M7f5oD9Luilb-NGvJYxsMA

4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=108065427&userid=119355&signature=O-tZT5EPXA5T8wcQ8QvxgA

5. trades/viewtrade.php?id=108090473&userid=119355&signature=mOyc63ULeQdfs53conRpxg

[Lee-Sins]

Wanted to get some advice on this as it's been a hot minute since I've done any bulk trading.

2013, 2015, and 2016 staff pets for recent 2023 pets.
I have a feeling that it's unfair to my side (staff pets).

[heartfades]

Wanted to get some advice on this as it's been a hot minute since I've done any bulk trading.

2013, 2015, and 2016 staff pets for recent 2023 pets.
I have a feeling that it's unfair to my side (staff pets).

this is very unfair to you. regardless of them even being staff pets -theyre asking for a lot of 2013 VUs and offering a few 2023 pets.

[wildspirt]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108108893&userid=52812&signature=eJA8CCDg0_Z1WcEyYvhp6A

Is this fair?? Store pet for older pets.

[StarryWish.]

pls delete posted twice.