The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Moonligh50]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107768939&userid=989119&signature=Bot8cwIM1MuUIPR0cQTZNg

Any help on this plzzz

[xenodeer]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107767019&userid=944259&signature=HeH7WQCeYwcVeKhQ-5syhQ
is this fair for an OMGSR?

[lucifer morningstar]

hoping for some advice on an item trade, here. based on my research the wizard token is worth 0.25n-0.5n, but I'm not entirely sure how much their side adds up to total. any input would be greatly appreciated! c:
lucifer

[NotHereAnymore]

Can I please get some help with these. Even if it's just on one of them... Thank you!

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107908294&userid=1064234&signature=WRqbccDa9nrms-D5l8aVOQ

Also wondering about these auction bids...

Bid #1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107553502&userid=1064234&signature=6qWuC5Ri8cZrL_y7_hvaWQ

Bid #2
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107926461&userid=1064234&signature=AM8NqRB0b0ytC9oCACDGUA

Bid #3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107946882&userid=1064234&signature=gX7IpAedQeQOnSi2Kw6uTA

Thank you in advance for any help!!!

[Sealipup]

Sorry that this is such a small trade but I'd like some advice please, as I'm unsure how different dates and rarities come into play!

[Ashki]

Sorry that this is such a small trade but I'd like some advice please, as I'm unsure how different dates and rarities come into play!

Personally, I'd say this is unfair to you. While their pet is older, both of your pets are 2 rarities higher than theirs, and even with the date difference I wouldn't trade an EUC for an UC. This is just my opinion though, ever since the rarity update it all depends on how you and your trading partner decide to value your pets!

[mochahearts]

HI! just want an opinion on theses
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107968930&userid=725734&signature=iiqBtW500-voEBm7fSJ9PQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107913448&userid=725734&signature=sMHb71VHtyhpi3-il34A5Q

[marmoris]

i plan to accept this but before i do, i want to make sure this is fair??

[birdiesong]

HI! just want an opinion on theses
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107968930&userid=725734&signature=iiqBtW500-voEBm7fSJ9PQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107913448&userid=725734&signature=sMHb71VHtyhpi3-il34A5Q

it's really hard to give solid opinions on these until the pets have received rarities.

looking at past events, most token trade-in pets become rare while the banner pets range from extremely uncommon to very rare. for the first one it could be fair, if you value the pets as a rare, as newer rares don't sell for too much C$ (but it also includes a banner pet which has high demand right now).

i'd say the second one might be fair (but the butterfly wolf pps was a freebie pet so its rarity is really up in the air, but i wouldn't value it higher than uncommon) due to the older uncommons they're offering. if anything i feel like they may be overpaying, but again, halloween pets are in high demand right now.

if you're really worried about it being completely fair i'd suggest waiting until the pets get their rarities to start trading!

[Laark]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107962032&userid=259920&signature=SeSJQrO6_0ezWpc4qJk_kA

What needs to be done to make this fair?