The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[waythereheythere]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107882070&userid=1059154&signature=H10RcTHNL9WBi5BTZq6CwA

is this a good C$ offer for my items?

[keayi]

I'd deeply appreciate help with this trade! (Arachnophobia warning! Working on trading my 2010 Malk Spider.) I'm okay if it's slightly off. They're offering to add a few event tokens if needed.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107857761&userid=1064234&signature=6aGr5JFC3-YMfKOsSjV7EQ

Can I please get some help with this?

Seems unfair to you. Even if it is a malk spider, it's still an early 2010 VR and you could probably find some better demand pets/older rares for it. Not too sure how event tokens are traded but I probably still would not take this trade if they weren't offering more than 40 (If 2010 VR = ~80c$ = 40 Tokens if sold at 2c$/ea)
I am being pretty subjective about this tho..

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107882070&userid=1059154&signature=H10RcTHNL9WBi5BTZq6CwA

is this a good C$ offer for my items?

32 Items for 16c$ that is 0,5c$/per item. They're all 2022-2023 (except for the first cat plushie.. I don't recongnize it) so this isn't a bad offer at all IMO. I think it's fair

[smartiez]

here

The fact that they're actively seeking out specifically rats definitely plays a role here -- thoughts?

[I'm tired]

here

The fact that they're actively seeking out specifically rats definitely plays a role here -- thoughts?

unfair to you because the rats are older!

[I'm tired]

i really like this trade but wanted to check to see if it was fair, i'm not great with rarities :p

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107893621&userid=305309&signature=xYHztJN99Nw8AILethOxMw

unfair to you!

[LionKingdom]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107869707&userid=925400&signature=waCSg6Qv9A9PGCpqpEYqVg

Reallyyyy need some help cause it's starting to rot

[keayi]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107869707&userid=925400&signature=waCSg6Qv9A9PGCpqpEYqVg

Reallyyyy need some help cause it's starting to rot

So, the Green Malk Dragon is worth 0,5 MA (Used to be 2-3 '09 rares but I keep seeing people ask for 3-4 which is 0,5 MA), and the Appy Malk is a former low advent (0,5 MA). The other malks (Panda, Skunk Malk Horses) would both be worth regular '09 VRs. All that being said, the dragons definitely have higher demand than the malk horses, but value-wise and objectively I do believe they are overpaying for your side (Plus they're offering a store worth about a 2010 rare).

[Clayflower.]

hello! I would love some help breaking down this trade if possible!

I value the Drink me at 6 nons

Are the values below accurate? I'm unsure of how accurate the store pets values are 100%! Any help comfirming or fixing my estimations is GREATLY appreciated!!!
-----

2 UR PPS Dragons = 4 non
Pink Sept = 2 MA
Spotted tribal = 5 MA
July Lioness = 3 MA
TOTAL = 5 Non

Water elemental cat = 1 MA
(dont know name 1 MA each) 2013 store pet dogs = 2 MA
Llama (1.5 MA) + corgi (1.5 MA) = 3 MA
2014 Dragon Store Pets (.5 MA each) = 1 MA
2014 Star Dog Store Pet = 1 MA
Dinosaur Store Pet = 1 MA
2014 Dog Store Pets (1 MA each) = 2 MA
TOTAL = 1 Non

--------

This one too please, much smaller <3

[whitedane]

Can someone help me with this? Thanks!

[Electric~Lime~Zebra]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107649585&userid=243464&signature=vpRS7ssnCZJ9h1XuUTG3dQ

Whats the ratio here for euc=r?