The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[heartfades]

Hi!
Could i get an opinion on these trades? I'd be really grateful c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107885288&userid=158024&signature=UPpCso1w_Jn54k_Ic3OfGg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107887403&userid=158024&signature=OoPKEZEsYZzmstAIMFRS2g

[regular;]

can someone help with this?? thank you!!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107885419&userid=714665&signature=CBzlrbl1_F7Med9SF2lxQw

[ornithpology]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107835539&userid=1039839&signature=eg1imepOm6v95DOFmO7PbQ
need help w this one! tysm!!

need a second opinion on this one if possible! thank you <3

[NotHereAnymore]

I'd deeply appreciate help with this trade! (Arachnophobia warning! Working on trading my 2010 Malk Spider.) I'm okay if it's slightly off. They're offering to add a few event tokens if needed.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107857761&userid=1064234&signature=6aGr5JFC3-YMfKOsSjV7EQ

Can I please get some help with this?

[heartfades]

Hi!
Could i get an opinion on these trades? I'd be really grateful c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107885288&userid=158024&signature=UPpCso1w_Jn54k_Ic3OfGg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107887403&userid=158024&signature=OoPKEZEsYZzmstAIMFRS2g

[keayi]

Hi!
Could i get an opinion on these trades? I'd be really grateful c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107885288&userid=158024&signature=UPpCso1w_Jn54k_Ic3OfGg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107887403&userid=158024&signature=OoPKEZEsYZzmstAIMFRS2g

1) So obviously they are both OMGSR so I don't think it would be unfair to swap them, but these are their former values/demands:

Tan Light Faced Rat = Former Low Sept = 0,5 MA
Hyena Bun = Former Low Main = 1 MA

2) Same with the first the OMGSRs are probably more 1:1 swappable, but here are their former values to help you decide:

Advent Gray Rat = Low Sept = 0,5 MA
Advent Albino/White Rat = Low Sept = 0,5 MA
Nick Horse = Former VR
Hyena Bun = 1 MA

If it were me I would probably prefer the 2nd because they are offering two OMGSRs for 1 and an ER, and one of the rats is a TD which might be valuable to someone else.

[Khonjin]

don't really know exlist worth anymore or what pets go for nowadays, any advice on this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107876282&userid=514763&signature=t72pVspzW7EFjj93fejxdw

[heartfades]

Hi!
Could i get an opinion on these trades? I'd be really grateful c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107885288&userid=158024&signature=UPpCso1w_Jn54k_Ic3OfGg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107887403&userid=158024&signature=OoPKEZEsYZzmstAIMFRS2g

1) So obviously they are both OMGSR so I don't think it would be unfair to swap them, but these are their former values/demands:

Tan Light Faced Rat = Former Low Sept = 0,5 MA
Hyena Bun = Former Low Main = 1 MA

2) Same with the first the OMGSRs are probably more 1:1 swappable, but here are their former values to help you decide:

Advent Gray Rat = Low Sept = 0,5 MA
Advent Albino/White Rat = Low Sept = 0,5 MA
Nick Horse = Former VR
Hyena Bun = 1 MA

If it were me I would probably prefer the 2nd because they are offering two OMGSRs for 1 and an ER, and one of the rats is a TD which might be valuable to someone else.

thank you so much for your help i really appreciate it c:

[kate,]

Can anyone check over this if it’s fair? (Large items trade)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107488384&userid=830519&signature=20iOV39QHj5Talv42yloWQ

[keayi]

don't really know exlist worth anymore or what pets go for nowadays, any advice on this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107876282&userid=514763&signature=t72pVspzW7EFjj93fejxdw

Zebras trade for between 0,75-1 NON and they are asking for two former low septembers (2 MA/ea) which is around 0,25 NON, so by "old rules" they are overpaying.
However, the septembers are new OMGSRs and may be worth a new base rarity (ie. all new OMGSRs are worth a new NON and are 1:1 swappable) .. but there doesn't seem to be a consensus yet.