The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[odin]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=106236284&userid=123271&signature=ABibkbeyJ2ocfJr_OmopLQ

Ope could I get some help again please? ( and ty for the help on my previous request!)

[LevyMcGarden55]

I know this isn’t a trade, but, about how many rares is fair to trade for a very rare? Assuming they’re all the same month. I just need a general benchmark or rule of thumb.

[YourLocalBreadDealer]

wondering if anyone can help with this store pets trade??


trades/viewtrade.php?id=106238924&userid=915982&signature=7YaUURicZ_h3EGtsgPwMWA

[kamukoma]

I know this isn’t a trade, but, about how many rares is fair to trade for a very rare? Assuming they’re all the same month. I just need a general benchmark or rule of thumb.

i usually say that 2 rares = a VR, but this may change depending on demand / the person youre trading with.

[kamukoma]

would this be under or over on my end?

youre overpaying

your side: 2010 rare

their side: 2019 rare, 2 2021 uncommons, 1 2022 common, 3 2022 uncommons, 3 2023 rares, 2 2023 unknowns. for the sake of addition lets say both unknowns turn out to be uncommons.

using the 2:1 rule, lets add up their side: this equals 1 2019 rare, 1 2020 rare, 1 2022 uncommon, 1 2022 common if my math is correct (im very tired so i might have added up wrong but this is an estimate). this is nowhere near as high of a value as a 2010 rare is worth

[starlord]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=106239703

I need opinions

[rintaro]

this trade?

got help! thanks <3

[LevyMcGarden55]

Thank you! I think I’ve drastically overpaid on a thing haha… good to know!

[Pixje]

this trade?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=106241601&userid=1048629&signature=5-gO9-sE6CvlRYr0ZIepyw

It's unfair to them. Your side is maximum 3 rares, I suspect they might be uncommon. They only need to offer 3 pets from the same year/3month rule rare to uncommon. They might be overpaying because the hype of the event, but I still think it's a bit unfair for them^^

[rintaro]

alright!