The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[zophronia]

was offered this trade. i am not good with rare trades. can anyone help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105964422&userid=1049101&signature=PbWaQ4fidkOCoVViAAtpcw

[keayi]

was offered this trade. i am not good with rare trades. can anyone help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105964422&userid=1049101&signature=PbWaQ4fidkOCoVViAAtpcw

I would accept. Even if you follow +2 rule (where you add two pets of the same value for every difference in year), 1 '10 R = ~20 '22-'23 R due to the difference in release, so this is underpay (I would value each of the items at a '23 common, currently).

[Che$hire Cat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105957335&userid=607005&signature=6TEe_YzXrp-GzsVdbfIFuw

Traded my store deer for the warriors, was this fair for me?

[Nocturnal Creatures]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105962187&userid=326970&signature=89IJnrdZN6yu3EgrqMHP9g

Just looking for opinions on my bid in this auction. I think my side comes to about 3-5 MA. And I know there are a few of the lions valued at 0.5 MA each. Just wondering if I should add more or not.

Thanks!!

[Cady55again]

Is this fair? I feel a bit iffy about it

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105972619&userid=973739&signature=tpGnyXjf48xfwFs7vggtig

edit: they canceled but i still need help ^^

edit 2: is this one also fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105975984&userid=973739&signature=S62kEtUS4_vLn7SGhrleLw

[deepseaolive]

Hi, thank you Shakespeare for helping with my last question!

I was wondering what people thought of this one? I’ve had a few people looking to trade for the 2017 PPS lately.

Thank you!

[keayi]

Hi, thank you Shakespeare for helping with my last question!

I was wondering what people thought of this one? I’ve had a few people looking to trade for the 2017 PPS lately.

Thank you!

Oh mobile so I can't link it currently (I will later), but I think this is unfair to you! The PPS Fairy Fox trades easily for 0,5 MA (about 3-4 2009 rares) Recent stores are only worth 2010-2011 R/ea, so it seems under!
---
'20 Store = 1 '09-'10 R?
6 '22-23 Stores = 6 '11 R = 1,5 '09 R

[NotHereAnymore]

Not sure if this thread is the right one to ask for help on an item trade. However, I have zero knowledge on what items are worth. I'm hoping to get some help...
Thank you in advance!!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105973873&userid=1064234&signature=KBWtbho9OuMhQm2q8jGkuw

[*Nevi Nova*]

Is this trade fair? I've been gone a while, so im not 100% on pets C$ value anymore

[Nocturnal Creatures]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105962187&userid=326970&signature=89IJnrdZN6yu3EgrqMHP9g

Just looking for opinions on my bid in this auction. I think my side comes to about 3-5 MA. And I know there are a few of the lions valued at 0.5 MA each. Just wondering if I should add more or not.

Thanks!!