The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[TeaSpicedDreams]

Hello all!
I have received this trade and was wondering whether or not it is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105935209&userid=979370&signature=75_97DKjSEiDQpA0u2e9Pw

[aladinchen]

Hello all!
I have received this trade and was wondering whether or not it is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105935209&userid=979370&signature=75_97DKjSEiDQpA0u2e9Pw

overpay on their side since the Griffins have some more value in my knowledge (the pps one for sure more) 2 x 2018 Store would be fine for the 2017 store

[Rosarianne]

Heyy ^=^

Would this be a fair trade?

thanks!

[aladinchen]

Heyy ^=^

Would this be a fair trade?

thanks!

nope, totaly not

[kalcifer]

Thoughts on this? This is a trade request I've received and my first event. So I don't know if thia is a good trade... Any help would be appreciated!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105917754&userid=1064234&signature=Bkh8Si4N4lEoYYBKOGeerA

probably best to get a second opinion but i think this is almost overpay on their side.
most people use the 2 for 1 rule so 2 2023 uncommons are 1 2022 uncommon.

since all of the event pets on your side are free (don't require tokens) then its normally safe to assume they are common-uncommon pets.

however there is always a possibility that those pets are rare.
additionally the current event pets, particularly the daily ones (eg; the squirrels) are in high demand since they are essentially a pet which if you miss you lose out and also those pets have unique line art so therefore most people value them slightly higher than typical demand.

overall it is up to you based on which pets you personally like more but at the end of the day i wouldn't personally say that it is unfair to you

(i hope that makes sense)

[I Dream A Dream]

Is this fair to me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105775378&userid=84041&signature=ABs3h6_eDAc-oFDSNsWFUw

[aladinchen]

Is this fair to me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105775378&userid=84041&signature=ABs3h6_eDAc-oFDSNsWFUw

No

[Zylafone]

is this fair? warrior cat https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105856303&userid=783721&signature=dpxI1QuwHJghWVkPSmHRjA

bump

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this fair? I have no knowledge of items.
If it's not what can added in pets or items.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105943004&userid=410864&signature=cwlaHYoeGHmdUY1B3bR8ZA

[007n7]

is this fair?