The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[$$Space moon$$]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626779&userid=1027143&signature=o6b8gGQI1DyxmNdem8LPTw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626756&userid=1027143&signature=Bw9c2hhM_SXBiim2BsoO0g
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626742&userid=1027143&signature=8gXJ1L3YMuUSmBHkglB17Q
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105624591&userid=1027143&signature=eu3TB1saJjW-x75Rk59_Pw
is this fair

[Starfire_Nebula]

Is this fair? Thanks
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626966&userid=1011831&signature=0AB1D7Fm0uHXqbOZx0mNVw

[keayi]

Is this fair? Thanks :)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626966&userid=1011831&signature=0AB1D7Fm0uHXqbOZx0mNVw

7 '10 R
'18 R
'20 R
'22 R

For;
2 '09 VR = 4 '09 R = 6 or 8 '10 R
'18 R

It's not bad. You honestly might be able to ask for one more '10 R but some of the malks might be worth it!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626779&userid=1027143&signature=o6b8gGQI1DyxmNdem8LPTw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626756&userid=1027143&signature=Bw9c2hhM_SXBiim2BsoO0g
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626742&userid=1027143&signature=8gXJ1L3YMuUSmBHkglB17Q
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105624591&userid=1027143&signature=eu3TB1saJjW-x75Rk59_Pw
is this fair

I'm sorry but you were asking for too much on all of these trades 💀

-snip-
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626290&userid=846503&signature=ZwzZAqNEmZeY0-V9MEGWJw what do yall think of this trade?

Heart swirl PPS = 1 MA
Spider bwolf = 0,5 MA
Pink Bwolf = Reg. '09 VR = 2 '09 R
April fools cat = 0,5 MA
Total = 2 MA added 2 '09 R

For;
Purple sleipnir = 3 MA or 0,25 Nons

They underpaid you

[moonbeam.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626535&userid=758444&signature=C4eGmyIUQVCsUVfAVQZVDg

Ik that it got cancelled but was I fair?

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105626535&userid=758444&signature=C4eGmyIUQVCsUVfAVQZVDg

Ik that it got cancelled but was I fair?

Thats the UR dog from 2009 and worth 0,5 Nons = 5-7 MA

You had
5 '09 R (vr incl)
5 '10 R = 2,5 '09 R (combined with ^ rares = 1 MA)
'11 R
Pin doll PPS cat = reg. '10 VR = 1 '09 R
Rainbow Corgi = 1,5 MA
Orange heavy stripe = 1 MA
2 RR (idk '09-'11 R?)

You probbaly had 3,5 MA at best, making it slightly under for the worth of the UR dog.

[kalcifer]

is this a fair trade?

[Riley ♥]

is this a fair trade?

Not at all, I wouldn't accept it

Their side:
3 regular VRs and 1 regular rare

Your side:
5 regular uncommons
Alice in Wonderland Bwolf worth 1 MA (3-4 2009 rares)
Green Robot Rat worth 1 MA (3-4 2009 rares)
Brown Cookie Dog (1 MA) (3-4 2009 rares)

Your side is worth way more

[incarna]

hello! any thoughts on this trade? not sure how zodiac dogs add up... trades/viewtrade.php?id=105622681&userid=433567&signature=SDQX0JvfX-XHrvpwylZRkA thank you in advance!

[auroraphoenix]

hello! any thoughts on this trade? not sure how zodiac dogs add up... trades/viewtrade.php?id=105622681&userid=433567&signature=SDQX0JvfX-XHrvpwylZRkA thank you in advance!

Zodiac Dog = 0.5 MA or 3-4 '09 rares

For

Nick Purple Toxic (0.5 MA) + Misc recent rares ('15 + '18 + '20 + '22 + '22) = 0.5 MA -- The recent rares don't add significant value to this side of the trade, just a nice touch

I'd say this is a fair trade! The Nick pet is fair alone c:

[incarna]

hello! any thoughts on this trade? not sure how zodiac dogs add up... trades/viewtrade.php?id=105622681&userid=433567&signature=SDQX0JvfX-XHrvpwylZRkA thank you in advance!

Zodiac Dog = 0.5 MA or 3-4 '09 rares

For

Nick Purple Toxic (0.5 MA) + Misc recent rares ('15 + '18 + '20 + '22 + '22) = 0.5 MA -- The recent rares don't add significant value to this side of the trade, just a nice touch

I'd say this is a fair trade! The Nick pet is fair alone c:

thank u!