The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[chaotic creativity]

i'm pretty rough on the values of the recent store pets, so some thoughts would be helpful for this trade!

[Audrey_Bee]

i'm pretty rough on the values of the recent store pets, so some thoughts would be helpful for this trade!

Very unfair, I believe your store is worth either a late 2010 or early 2011 rare, their side is not much over 2013 rare <3

[robotpetunias]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105306842&userid=863694&signature=mEmgrknpbDc6zUQto3JknA

Thank you!!

[NotHereAnymore]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105302842&userid=1064234&signature=P2P6xD3KE2cHOSEL6PP7cA

[possumfriend]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105306956&userid=1031588&signature=Wvy9tlm_oskeiXKB6UPEGg
is this fair?

[angst]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105297041&userid=862226&signature=jX2Ojr9iaVtR5-HPyUZ3_Q

Is this fair for a joker dog?
I really like the store zebra but idk-

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105297235&userid=862226&signature=HfXGvYL-4Ts_kL5UhOpwKw

And this for the joker? Lord save me it's a zebra c': ah

Zebras have horrible demand and are barely worth 0.75-1 Non. A Joker dog trades consistently for at least 1.5-2 Nons. I would highhly recommend not trading a Joker for just a zebra...

For the other trade;

Heart valentines PPS = .5-.75 MA
Blue aussie = reg. '09 R
Forest guardian = 2 MA
Carousel horse = 2 MA
Alien dog = 1 MA
'12 Store = 1 MA
Koi dog = 0.5 MA
'15 Deer = 1 MA
2 '15 Store critters = 0.5-1 MA/ea = 1-2 MA
'17 Store = 1-2 '09 R
'18 Store = 1 '09 R
'09 R
Red rose dog = 0.25 N
'23 Store = '11 R
-------
Total '09 R = 4-5 = 0.75 MA
Total MA = 9-10.25 (+ .75 MA) = 9.75-11 MA = 0.75-1 NON
0.25 N (+ 0.75-1.0 N) = Total = 1-1.25 N

They're short at least another 0.25 N in my opinion.

Oooh okay I sent this and here's what I got!

True date Heart Valentine's - 1-1.75MA
Blue Aussie (rarity wise worth an 09 but usually trades for more due to its popularity) - 2-3 09s
Forest guardian - 2MA
Carousel horse - 2MA
Alien - 1MA
Jujube bird - 1MA
Koi dog - .5-1MA
Heart deer - 1MA
Raccoon - .5MA
Skunk - .5MA
17 store - 2 09s
09 rare
18 store - 1-2 09s
23 store - 11 rare
Red rose dog - .25non or 3-4MA
--
Lowest end: 13.5MA
Highest end: 15ish MA

I can totally see an argument that I need to add! Maybe I can throw in something else. I do feel like in general bulk store pets are kinda hard to come by? And that should maybe count for something, especially in this case where the joker isn't very rare where rarity is considered but has a ton of demand and my pets, as store pets, will grow in worth and some are possibly rare than the joker (and definitely will be one day) but lack the demand power of the joker. I guess taking it and it's high side plus the bulk store pet power I felt it was a good offer for a re-releases joker!

Maybe I'll try to add some more old VRs to make up the difference; I'll think about it either in this offer or in the future, and will do my counting more carefully!

^^ thank you so much for looking over it

[El.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105307038&userid=200501&signature=U_ubLrH3ICKG_0QS5Q9RNw hi, is this good? I feel like it’s both fair and not fair i’m not sure how to add up the more recent pets and not sure about demand

[PastelDog]

So, I'm not the best with item trades or large trades. I'm hoping someone can help me.

Pet trade is here - mostly uncommons with a few rares

Items trade is here

[possumfriend]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105306956&userid=1031588&signature=Wvy9tlm_oskeiXKB6UPEGg
is this fair?

[Che$hire Cat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105308399&userid=607005&signature=eAIBFjIhGxDefMIwie94tg

Would this store pet be a fair trade for my ‘09 lion?