The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lex.]

Big list trade I need help with. Looking for value help and opinions!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105267054&userid=39760&signature=ehm7Bch_CNBfpUNX-fiBIA

UR Tiger: 6n
UR Pastel: About 3n [From what I've seen]
9n total

Their Side:

Dogtag: 1.5-2n
NonSwirl + Nontag: 2n
Moonswirl: 2-2.5
UR Pumpkin Pie: 1.5-2n
UR Holly: 1.5n
8.5 total low end
10n high end

It's tough because of their value ranges, but their side is worth more if you value them at the higher end.
The UR pastel is also still high in demand because it's a new UR, so the value could potentially drop. I personally would take the trade, but it's totally up to you to decide if you want the pets they're offering or not <3

[velocira]

is this fair? im not too sure on the 2014 cat thrown in trades/viewtrade.php?id=105266258&userid=825907&signature=uLjX3iv-IXCKwpdzlaTWKA

still looking for an opinion on this ;u;

[mike ehrmantraut]

Hello! Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105273528&userid=918514&signature=eeXTnFKEPce7i_1GmWky-A

[Lex.]

Hello! Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105273528&userid=918514&signature=eeXTnFKEPce7i_1GmWky-A

Their Side: 2.25-2.75N

Your Side: 2.5-3N

I'd say underpay on their side, I personally wouldn't take that trade.

[Viiperfang]

help im bad with trades. is this fair?

[EmeryAmrik]

is this fair? im not too sure on the 2014 cat thrown in trades/viewtrade.php?id=105266258&userid=825907&signature=uLjX3iv-IXCKwpdzlaTWKA

still looking for an opinion on this ;u;

Just looking at your 2014 UC Cat vs their 21 2021 UC equivalents I would say this trade is unfair towards you. Using the "2 UCs of the following year = 1 UC of the previous year" rule they'd need 128 2021 UCs to match a 2014 UC (hopefully my math is right on that but either way there's a large age gap). That's only considering your 2014 UC cat against what they're offering, considering the rest of what they want from you I'd say it's already pretty unfair.

[Lex.]

help im bad with trades. is this fair?

Overpay on their side as the rats add value that's not needed, also the knight suits are worth more than your items.

[~Heizou~]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105273777&userid=957390&signature=ollYp_c0IJME_ngwEiQG4A

And this one!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105273828&userid=957390&signature=uJeKuYrYCptK5i1kPLa21g

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105273836&userid=957390&signature=vhQSeY2rHm8agH9TGhQRLQ

[Lex.]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105273777&userid=957390&signature=ollYp_c0IJME_ngwEiQG4A

Technically it's overpay on your side because of the lion, but the UR Pickle doesn't have great demand as opposed to the nonjewel :)

Also, the trade for the warriors is overpay on the warrior side :)

[Checkinder]

Is this fair?