The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Latibule]

There are 5 rat wings, not 4.
If the whole set is worth 1 MA, then one should be worth 0.2 MA or 1 R (because 1 MA/5 wings= 0.2 MA, and if 0.5 MA = 3-4 '09 then 0.2 MA = 1 '09 R at most). In general, I would value a single item from 2009 to be a '09 R anyways, so..

You might be able to get them to add a little to get to the worth of that 1 '09 R.

I think what they meant is the set of one colour (4 items for one set) is worth 1 MA.
So it'll be 0.25 MA which is 1.5-2 09 rare for one item of a set

Thank you both for your help aha
Yes, sorry I tried to figure out how to word it but I did mean only 1 item out of the set ; Rat butterfly wings, rat butterfly tail, rat butterfly paws, rat butterfly antennae.

Sorry for confusing you Kaeyi!

[RadioactiveRenegade]

Hi! I was sent this trade. I feel like if I accept this as is, it would be very unfair on their end because I think the Dec 18th pet they are offering is worth quite a bit more? However, I would like a few other opinions as I haven't really traded much in a while.

Thanks!

[EchothroughDarkness]

Hi! I was sent this trade. I feel like if I accept this as is, it would be very unfair on their end because I think the Dec 18th pet they are offering is worth quite a bit more? However, I would like a few other opinions as I haven't really traded much in a while.

Thanks!

They was the ones underpaying.
That pps dog is the celestial pps. Worth 1 MA

A kitsune is worth 2 MA.

[screamingrainfrog]

Hi! Is this fair?
Thanks in advance!

[Lex.]

Hi! Is this fair?
Thanks in advance!

For reference, yes this is fair! Both are from the same year, 2009.

[river blossom]

raven dog help pt 182564 so their side is 7.5 nons I think? so technically they would be overpaying I think?

[Lex.]

raven dog help pt 182564 so their side is 7.5 nons I think? so technically they would be overpaying I think?

Their side is 7 nons on the highest side, 6.5 I believe on the lower side. Still overpay. It's up to you on whether you'd like to trade the raven for those pets :)

[mymelody<3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105261572&userid=1064257&signature=Qj6LMWTnc3zq-doBxaOPNg
Is this fair? Tysm to any help!♡

[Lex.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105261572&userid=1064257&signature=Qj6LMWTnc3zq-doBxaOPNg
Is this fair? Tysm to any help!♡

If I'm not wrong, mal smiley's can go for 2 09 rares? I haven't had one in a while so a second opinion would be great!
Warriors go for 3-4 09s, so I think either way it would be unfair to you <3

[andreá]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105246172&userid=913157&signature=iAi8n6D1ajFsGZHYzoUzgg
is this fair?