The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Popper_Cornz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105257325&userid=1051831&signature=BSV_P8-o74RIA3LI9mzd8A

I'm not good with items, Any advice on if this is fair?

Unfair to you, all of their items are recent and do not add up to the value of your rare.

Thank you so much!

[The Shattered one]

ignore I solved it

[Latibule]

Just wondering on what could make this trade a bit more fair to me.
I know the rat wings are worth a ma for the set, but I'm not sure what that would mean for just 1 item out of the 4 set.
Any help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105256815&userid=926807&signature=FsD2pJSjkRtpkbkt6FaAGA

[keayi]

Just wondering on what could make this trade a bit more fair to me.
I know the rat wings are worth a ma for the set, but I'm not sure what that would mean for just 1 item out of the 4 set.
Any help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105256815&userid=926807&signature=FsD2pJSjkRtpkbkt6FaAGA

There are 5 rat wings, not 4.
If the whole set is worth 1 MA, then one should be worth 0.2 MA or 1 R (because 1 MA/5 wings= 0.2 MA, and if 0.5 MA = 3-4 '09 then 0.2 MA = 1 '09 R at most). In general, I would value a single item from 2009 to be a '09 R anyways, so..

2 '11 R
(1 '11 R = 0.5 '10 R = .25 '09 R)

For:
Rat Wings 2009 Halloween = 1 '09 R
'Harry' = 2011 Easter = 1 '11 UC/R

You might be able to get them to add a little to get to the worth of that 1 '09 R.

[Audrey_Bee]

Just wondering on what could make this trade a bit more fair to me.
I know the rat wings are worth a ma for the set, but I'm not sure what that would mean for just 1 item out of the 4 set.
Any help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105256815&userid=926807&signature=FsD2pJSjkRtpkbkt6FaAGA

There are 5 rat wings, not 4.
If the whole set is worth 1 MA, then one should be worth 0.2 MA or 1 R (because 1 MA/5 wings= 0.2 MA, and if 0.5 MA = 3-4 '09 then 0.2 MA = 1 '09 R at most). In general, I would value a single item from 2009 to be a '09 R anyways, so..

2 '11 R
(1 '11 R = 0.5 '10 R = .25 '09 R)

For:
Rat Wings 2009 Halloween = 1 '09 R
'Harry' = 2011 Easter = 1 '11 UC/R

You might be able to get them to add a little to get to the worth of that 1 '09 R.

I think what they meant is the set of one colour (4 items for one set) is worth 1 MA.
So it'll be 0.25 MA which is 1.5-2 09 rare for one item of a set

[keayi]

Just wondering on what could make this trade a bit more fair to me.
I know the rat wings are worth a ma for the set, but I'm not sure what that would mean for just 1 item out of the 4 set.
Any help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105256815&userid=926807&signature=FsD2pJSjkRtpkbkt6FaAGA

There are 5 rat wings, not 4.
If the whole set is worth 1 MA, then one should be worth 0.2 MA or 1 R (because 1 MA/5 wings= 0.2 MA, and if 0.5 MA = 3-4 '09 then 0.2 MA = 1 '09 R at most). In general, I would value a single item from 2009 to be a '09 R anyways, so..

2 '11 R
(1 '11 R = 0.5 '10 R = .25 '09 R)

For:
Rat Wings 2009 Halloween = 1 '09 R
'Harry' = 2011 Easter = 1 '11 UC/R

You might be able to get them to add a little to get to the worth of that 1 '09 R.

I think what they meant is the set of one colour (4 items for one set) is worth 1 MA.
So it'll be 0.25 MA which is 1.5-2 09 rare for one item of a set

Ooooooooooooooh. Thanks girl ,;p

[Audrey_Bee]

Ooooooooooooooh. Thanks girl ,;p

<3

[sonico]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105258638&userid=826205&signature=EzIJb8kJuUKlrynzPlenCg

help me

[s a r o s]

Help please? (I've been looking for the ace mice so I don't mind having them in the trade)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105258604&userid=561589&signature=ybr-NW51hu8F7WS2a7ymZQ

[beemo]

Help please? (I've been looking for the ace mice so I don't mind having them in the trade)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105258604&userid=561589&signature=ybr-NW51hu8F7WS2a7ymZQ

unfair to them. their 2019 store pet is worth a 2009 rare, while your store pets are worth a 2010 rare + 2011 rare.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105258638&userid=826205&signature=EzIJb8kJuUKlrynzPlenCg

help me

very, very unfair to you. the flamingo doesn't have great demand but still fetches close to it's worth, which is 2-2.5 nons. they aren't offering even a nons worth.