The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[EchothroughDarkness]

Are these fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105231169&userid=410864&signature=bJ9uoPEeVEz-5uZq4Jk_JA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105231092&userid=410864&signature=rZlropFekm7bzcHOjibclA

[autumn magpie]

hey y'all, could i have some feedback on this trade please? Thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105223920&userid=44278&signature=eJajjVSuE3DKmXJHsh51DQ

[Audrey_Bee]

hey y'all, could i have some feedback on this trade please? Thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105223920&userid=44278&signature=eJajjVSuE3DKmXJHsh51DQ

Hey! Their side is worth a 2021 rare so it would be unfair to you by quite a bit <3

[fish]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105228254&userid=551103&signature=SRzlBb78hJyQsI4YxfHAdA

hello!! can anybody help?? i’ve gotten a lot of offers for this guy so i want to make sure i’m making a good choice (: thank you so much in advance

[morta∣ity]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105228254&userid=551103&signature=SRzlBb78hJyQsI4YxfHAdA

hello!! can anybody help?? i’ve gotten a lot of offers for this guy so i want to make sure i’m making a good choice (: thank you so much in advance

this is definently not fair to you, their side doesn't even add up to a '15 rare and i'd assume since you're getting a bunch of offers it has some demand so it'd be even more unfair

[Checkinder]

Could I have a bit of help on an item trade? Thank you!

Edit; this one too!

Hi! For the second trade, I believe the dog plushie is worth an '09 rare+, so it would be very unfair to you. Someone correct me if I'm wrong! ^^

Thank you! Bump on the first trade, perhaps?

[Audrey_Bee]

Could I have a bit of help on an item trade? Thank you!

Edit; this one too!

Hi! For the second trade, I believe the dog plushie is worth an '09 rare+, so it would be very unfair to you. Someone correct me if I'm wrong! ^^

Thank you! Bump on the first trade, perhaps?

I would like to quickly put out there that the second trade: the dog plush is worth 1 Mid Advent which is 6-9 09 rares, not 1!<3

As for the first trade its quite tricky without automatically knowing dated off the top of my head but I know both Berry items have been valued at 1 09 rare each so they're a fair trade. You seem to have more older items though, I know the candles are old items and their oldest items they're offering are current store ones. Pls wait for a proper response if you like but I personally would make a couple of smaller trades with them to make valuing easier. Or if you take a look on the how much is this item worth thread and use the search function, that's a handy tool. But I don't see anything valuable other than the berries so they're likely all an uncommon from their release year (the none store items, that is) so that might help you or others to value !

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105228254&userid=551103&signature=SRzlBb78hJyQsI4YxfHAdA

hello!! can anybody help?? i’ve gotten a lot of offers for this guy so i want to make sure i’m making a good choice (: thank you so much in advance

This is very unfair to you date wise. The high demand you’re experiencing with this pet is probably due to the fact that most advent and event pets usually have a higher demand since they’re special releases. c:

[keayi]

Are these fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105231169&userid=410864&signature=bJ9uoPEeVEz-5uZq4Jk_JA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105231092&userid=410864&signature=rZlropFekm7bzcHOjibclA

1)
2 '12 R = 1 '11 R
'23 Unknown (will probably common-uncommon so may be swappable for the '22 C)

For:
2 '11 R
1 '22 C

2 '12 R = 1 '11 R so unfair to you.

2)
1 '10 VR = 2 '10 R = 1 '09 R
1 '11 R = .5 '10 R = .25 '09 R
1 '14 R = .5 '13 R = .25 '12 R = .125 '11 R = .06 '10 R = 0.03 '09 R
1 '15 R
1 '16 R
Rerelease tess dragon = 2009 VR = 1-2 '09 R
Only worth around 2.28-3.28

For:
2015 Stripe Tail Critters = 0.5 - 1 MA = 3-9 '09 R

Upto you. Worth the lower end of it's value. I personally wouldn't take it

[catplushie]

was this fair? i think i overpayed a bit, and i don't mind, i just wanted to double check haha. thanks in advance!