The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kim24568]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105221435&userid=11049&signature=Mw8u0Y4pK4yOe_3MsCE7Bg

Was this fair or did i vallue something wrong?
Thought both are round 19x 09 rare
If it is unfair what should i offer to make it fair?

Thank you for your help

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105221435&userid=11049&signature=Mw8u0Y4pK4yOe_3MsCE7Bg

Was this fair or did i vallue something wrong?
Thought both are round 19x 09 rare
If it is unfair what should i offer to make it fair?

Thank you for your help

1 '09 R
1 '14 Store = 0.5 MA = 3-4 '09 R
1 '15 Store = 0.5 MA = 3-4 '09 R
2 '16 Store = 0.5 MA/ea = 1 MA = 6-9 '09 R
Total = 13-18 '09 R

For:
Bows x2 = 2009 = 2 '09 R
Party Hat x4 = 2009 = 4 '09 R
Blowers x2 = 2009 = 2 '09 R
Fairy = 2009 = 1 '09 R
Wolf/Horse figures x6 = 2009 = 6 '09 R
Penguin plush = ? couldnt find
Horsehair wig x5 = 2011 = 5 '11 UC/R
Assorted animal Plushies x6 = ? couldnt find but they're recent
Total = at least 15 '09 R worth (without counting the penguin, wigs, and recent plushies) howwwevverr ...

The thing with items is a lot of people don't value them as much as pets, so some of the '09 items might only be valued as a '09 uncommon to people, especially the blowers, party hats, and anniversary bows - just because they're not as in-demand. So that might cut your values in half. This is mostly opinion-based so I can't say forshure if that was your partner's reasoning!

[matthew patel]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105201455&userid=1074987&signature=SqRpucdd1VLf-jqFxc1aBw
they offered this this time. I think they’re under because the gryphon is worth 1-2 ‘09 rares, right?

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105201455&userid=1074987&signature=SqRpucdd1VLf-jqFxc1aBw
they offered this this time. I think they’re under because the gryphon is worth 1-2 ‘09 rares, right?

Yep! 2017 Stores = 1-2 '09 R so very unfair to you :) I would recommend saving it for another store or some older rares (if you're looking for some), someone will offer it! Unfortunately the value of that gryphon is worth tooons of recent rares ^^"

[matthew patel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105201455&userid=1074987&signature=SqRpucdd1VLf-jqFxc1aBw
they offered this this time. I think they’re under because the gryphon is worth 1-2 ‘09 rares, right?

Yep! 2017 Stores = 1-2 '09 R so very unfair to you :) I would recommend saving it for another store or some older rares (if you're looking for some), someone will offer it! Unfortunately the value of that gryphon is worth tooons of recent rares ^^"

thank you, mate! y’all are lifesavers, i swear

[SaschaBT]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105221283&userid=1004366&signature=Eup1iSvz5fnJfJfb5z4KLw

Is this fair for one Lorwolf Kickstarter companion? It includes 1 OMG so rare pet

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105224213&userid=410864&signature=xBNmHNabMI3FSEviUM95aQ

[Checkinder]

Could I have a bit of help on an item trade? Thank you!

Edit; this one too!

[Fizzlepoppi]

hello is this a fair trade? trades/viewtrade.php?id=105224436&userid=1077955&signature=QQcudx2MoLGvgGA1Nv6HPA

[Corey Taylor]

Could I have a bit of help on an item trade? Thank you!

Edit; this one too!

Hi! For the second trade, I believe the dog plushie is worth an '09 rare+, so it would be very unfair to you. Someone correct me if I'm wrong! ^^