The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[致你 ౨ৎ]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105196541&userid=780015&signature=8iraONCyl6D_YksOxCTmEg how much c$ is worth?

[LaceWhiskey]

I'm not very good when it comes to items.
Would anyone be able to tell me if this is fair or not?

I know pet-wise it isn't, but I'm wondering if the items make up the gap.

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105194306&userid=15405&signature=HxsGf9PucHiHBL_g4aYtcg

Is this fair? Taking out the re-release 09 dog and it’s for one of the sets dachshund or deer.

'23 Store Set = '11 R/ea (x5) = 5 '11 R worth

I'll count everything down to '11 rares. Skipping the Dec 18th dog

6 '12 UC (commons included) = 3 '11 UC = 1.5 '11 R
12 '13 UC (c included) = 6 '12 UC = 3 '11 UC = 1.5 '11 R
18 '14 C (very commons included) = 9 '13 C = 4.5 '12 C = 2.25 '11 C = 1.125 '11 UC = 0.5625 '11 R
10 '14 UC = 5 '13 UC = 2.5 '12 UC = 1.25 '11 UC = 0.625 '11 R
9 '15 VC = 4.5 '14 UC = 2.25 '13 UC = 1.125 '12 UC = .56 '11 UC = 0.28 '11 R
16 '15 C = 8 '14 C = 4 '13 C = 2 '12 C = 1 '11 C = .5 '11 UC = .25 '11 R
12 '15 UC = 6 '14 UC = 3 '13 UC = 1.5 '12 UC = .75 '11 UC = .375 '11 R
12.5 '16 C (vc included) = 6.25 '15 C = 3.125 '14 C = 1.56 '13 C = 0.78 '12 C = 0.39 '11 C = .19 '11 UC = 0.09 '11 R
13 '17 C (vc included) = 6.5 '16 C = 3.25 '15 C = 1.625 '14 C = 0.8125 '13 C = .4 '12 C = .2 '11 C = .1 '11 UC = .05 '11 R
----------- everything here and up is worth around 5.2325 '11 R. the rest will maaaaybe add half a rare
1 '18 UC
4 '19 UC
5 '20 C
8 '20 UC
1 '21 UC
2 '22 C
3 '22 R

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105196541&userid=780015&signature=8iraONCyl6D_YksOxCTmEg how much c$ is worth?

Everyone sets their own C$ prices but 5 C$ for a 2020 rare is pretty common. I usually look for 4-5 C$ per '20 R, so I say it's fair.

I'm not very good when it comes to items.
Would anyone be able to tell me if this is fair or not?

I know pet-wise it isn't, but I'm wondering if the items make up the gap.

Items are usually worth an UC/R pet of the same year they were released. This fluctuates up-down in rarity based on demand, quantity, usability, etc..

Paint = 2017 April Fools (x2)
Love Potion, Blush = 2015 Valentine's (x2)
Cloud Monkey = 2016 Chinese NY
Ornaments, Coal, Bell = 2015 XMAS (x21)
Rose Bracelet = 2017 Valentine's

It's a nice bulk of items, even if they were all valued at commons that's more than makes up for the value of the '21 rare in my opinion. If you like the items go for it

[LaceWhiskey]

I'm not very good when it comes to items.
Would anyone be able to tell me if this is fair or not?

I know pet-wise it isn't, but I'm wondering if the items make up the gap.

give me a hot sec to look for the items' year

Not sure on a few of them, but here's the ones I've found:

Small Hat - ?
Gelt - Hanukkah 2017
Sunflower - ?
Sigh Bubble - ?
Rose Bracelet - ?
Colored Lights - Christmas 2016
Tree Topper - Christmas 2016
Cloud Monkey - Chinese New Year 2016
Coal x9 - Christmas 2015
Oranaments x12 - Christmas 2015
Pink Love Potion - Valentine's 2015
Cute Blush - Valentine's 2015
Ick Bubbles - ?
Paint Splotch x2 - ?

[Ashki]

With demand, is this fair?

I've seen them valued around .5 MA but I've gotten offers around .75 MA so I'm not certain. Thanks for any advice!

[keayi]

With demand, is this fair?

I've seen them valued around .5 MA but I've gotten offers around .75 MA so I'm not certain. Thanks for any advice!

The way I've been seeing them trade it's 0.5 MA AT LEAST. I do believe the '13 store is worth 1 MA, so they're valued at .5 MA in this trade... it meets their base-value but if you've been getting higher offers, why take this one? ;p

[very_tiny_birb]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105192215&userid=37222&signature=GUdjDJMFhMx0yky3T7tG6g
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105196938&userid=37222&signature=bGVRdz9Brp7BBum7O7v6Bw

What do you think of these trades? The first is the original and the second is my counter offer. I'm trying to learn as much as I can about trading so I want to make sure I'm fair in the future

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105154805&userid=410864&signature=BO2lFguXwLwYxPFaOqSikw

[Griffin Torrens]

What's the current value of the store scarfs?
Is this fair? Thank you!

[Audrey_Bee]

What's the current value of the store scarfs?
Is this fair? Thank you!

Not fair at all. The store scarves go for 0.5 nons excluding this particular scarf that goes for 0.25 nons so it's worth a lot more than this!<3