The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105191384&userid=644087&signature=AzBkDvAHzM5qReQ4pciRdQ
Advice on this trade? I haven’t been on much the past few months so I’m not too sure of the Sunjewel’s worth. Thank you to anyone who can help!

TD Zodiacs = 0.5 MA/ea = 1 MA
'14 Store Robo Cat = 0.5 MA
'14 Store Dragon Cats = 0.5 MA/ea = 1 MA
Malk Dragons = 0.25 N/ea = 0.5 N

Total MA = 2.5 MA = <.25 N
Total Nons = at most 0.75 N

Sunjewel = trading for 3 N consistently
'13 R
'15 UC

I have seen the malk dragons go for a little more than .25 N but just using base values this is most likely unfair to you!

[matthew patel]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105191559&userid=1074987&signature=PsrUu_tz-XuTrBYfXoi1Eg
i’m not sure about item values, would anyone mind helping?

[river blossom]

I am so bad with lists LOL

[OMGit`sKairi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105191559&userid=1074987&signature=PsrUu_tz-XuTrBYfXoi1Eg
i’m not sure about item values, would anyone mind helping?

The witch hat, balloon, and arm socks are from Hallowe'en 2017.

In my experience items are typically valued at a common or uncommon of their release year. And your pet is a staff litter pet, which could possibly be valued higher than its base value.

Very unfair to you, in my opinion.

Edit: By my estimation, if the 2:1 rule were to be used, it would take 64 uncommons from 2017 to equal one uncommon from 2011.

[keayi]

I am so bad with lists LOL

Yellow Toxic = 0.5 N and usually trades as such
Gray Mini Husky = 1 MA

Red X PPS = 0.25 N
Santa Hat Dog = 1 MA
Floppy Blood Dog = 1 MA
Purple Star Bobtail = 1 MA
'12 Store = 1 MA

4 MA = 0.25 N (+ 0.25 = 0.5 N total on their side)

their side is fair for just the yellow toxic, however the added 1 MA on your side is making you overpay.

[matthew patel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105191559&userid=1074987&signature=PsrUu_tz-XuTrBYfXoi1Eg
i’m not sure about item values, would anyone mind helping?

The witch hat, balloon, and arm socks are from Hallowe'en 2017.

In my experience items are typically valued at a common or uncommon of their release year. And your pet is a staff litter pet, which could possibly be valued higher than its base value.

Very unfair to you, in my opinion.

Edit: By my estimation, if the 2:1 rule were to be used, it would take 64 uncommons from 2017 to equal one uncommon from 2011.

thank you so much! :3

[Che$hire Cat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105194747&userid=607005&signature=apHSrOX0-G7rgNZuQhz9aQ

Is this a fair trade for my bumblebee spider? Ik it can be worth up to .5 nons. I sent the offer but am I sure if the other side is fair

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105194747&userid=607005&signature=apHSrOX0-G7rgNZuQhz9aQ

Is this a fair trade for my bumblebee spider? Ik it can be worth up to .5 nons. I sent the offer but am I sure if the other side is fair

Regular '09 VR = 2 '09 R / like 0.25 MA
Starry Owl PPS = 1 MA
Elemental Malk Cats = 1 MA *edit* some people might trade them for 1-2 MA, something to think on

Their side is worth around 2.25 MA. I don't think the reg. malk cat has an ex-list value. If you want to get the 0.25-0.5 N worth of the spider, they need to add a couple more MA's.

[CristalStar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105186390&userid=983838&signature=4EJc4_L7xprBPXxgEmOPAw

how would I be able to make this trade fair if it is not?

[Audrey_Bee]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105186390&userid=983838&signature=4EJc4_L7xprBPXxgEmOPAw

how would I be able to make this trade fair if it is not?

The 2020 uncommon pet would be fair enough for the rare