The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[WispyWoods]

Hello! I recently got a trade that has made me very indecisive oops. I've been trying to educate myself more on rarities so here is my question and trade. Also if I am wrong about anything with rarity then please do correct me!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103169733&userid=572597&signature=33Uv0Jwwpcupqny6QCWEZA

I think the UR holly dog goes for 1.5 nons, and I know the noncoon is 1 non and the sorb is 0.5 non. So it seems to be a straight even trade. But my question is whether or not other people would accept this offer personally :) multiple opinions welcome and thank you!

[Falco]

Hello! I recently got a trade that has made me very indecisive oops. I've been trying to educate myself more on rarities so here is my question and trade. Also if I am wrong about anything with rarity then please do correct me!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103169733&userid=572597&signature=33Uv0Jwwpcupqny6QCWEZA

I think the UR holly dog goes for 1.5 nons, and I know the noncoon is 1 non and the sorb is 0.5 non. So it seems to be a straight even trade. But my question is whether or not other people would accept this offer personally multiple opinions welcome and thank you!

I agree with you! It seems like a fair trade to me
I would accept it, but I also love the UR holly

[Vampie!]

A little bit of a large trade, but I need someone's help
The trade in question
They're asking for these pets, plus my rares+ folder, plus all of my uncommons and below. Would this be fair, and even without asking about fairness, is this a wise trade? What's the Nick Uni worth, would trading it for something I want be easy/hard?

[~Loki~]

I know it’s technically fair, would you personally accept?

[Falco]

I know it’s technically fair, would you personally accept?

I wouldn't. The store pets don't come back to the game ever, but the pets on their side can. In my opinion, store lists have better demand.

[I am Pokémon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176307&userid=1025137&signature=nKnqOpAzVOiPW2EoCrxeXQ



Is this a fair trade I accepted the trade but now idk if it was that fair (the 2018 pet was a store pet)

[2b2t]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176307&userid=1025137&signature=nKnqOpAzVOiPW2EoCrxeXQ



Is this a fair trade I accepted the trade but now idk if it was that fair (the 2018 pet was a store pet)

oh, oh no, oh dear. this isn't fair to you at all. that's a zodiac dog. it's worth 0.5 MA (3-4 '09 rares) and im quite afraid the c$ doesn't make it fair either. 2018 store pets are woth a late '09 rare and 2022 store pets are worth an early '11 rare. if i were you i'd ask them if you could get a tradeback.

i encourage you to ask this thread before accepting a trade for a december 18th pet, however.

[Vampie!]

A little bit of a large trade, but I need someone's help
The trade in question
They're asking for these pets, plus my rares+ folder, plus all of my uncommons and below. Would this be fair, and even without asking about fairness, is this a wise trade? What's the Nick Uni worth, would trading it for something I want be easy/hard?

[rainbowbanda]

Hi I was wondering if this would be a fair trade? Going by horrors worth it says .5 non is worth 1000 C$ so I was just wondering if it would be over pay for 1200 C$

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176035&userid=868291&signature=sHUEPjePw97u_Ds21NmObw

[Animall]

Hi I was wondering if this would be a fair trade? Going by horrors worth it says .5 non is worth 1000 C$ so I was just wondering if it would be over pay for 1200 C$

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176035&userid=868291&signature=sHUEPjePw97u_Ds21NmObw

It's not uncommon for people to ask for more c$ than it is worth because c$ generally has low demand and people prefer to keep their pets instead of selling them. I would say that this is fair but it's entirely up to you on how you utilize and value your c$. I personally refuse to overpay for pets when I buy with c$.