The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Deficient]

I have a PPS dragon I'm trying to figure out what's a fair trade for, someone on here told me only the 3rd one is fair, just trying to check and get more information.

trade 1
trade 2
trade 3
Thanks for the help!

I've posted this a bunch of times and the only response I got was from one of the people that traded me telling me their trade is fair -_- pls help

Trades 1 and 2 are absolutely not fair to you. The first one I don’t even think values up to .5 a non, and the dragon easily trades for at least 2 nons right now. Trade 2 has the cucumber which is very hard to trade off, and I believe just barely trades for a non due to how poor its demand can be, the remaining pets do not make up for the difference, the Dragon Cat PPS has demand, but maybe only about .25-.5non in value.

Trade three is “fair” in terms of the amount of C$. 5,000 C$ can trade for about 2.5 nons right now. The other pets are nice Store pets, but nothing significant. If you like trading C$ you could go for it, but personally I’d rather just trade for other lists.

[Screemnigcheesepuff]

Any help with either of these two trades would be appreciated,
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=103124410&userid=684994&signature=4pvINNOl5XGwxFPDwPBpNg

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=103151737&userid=684994&signature=CowWfiAR4xK5iLUrDYMcVw
Thankyou:)

[Animall]

1. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103161992&userid=1011486&signature=eJTUtgMOLiGGtVqJcTzk1w

2. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103162046&userid=1011486&signature=2NDw2bjSFV-hP_ORmyMFVQ

which is a good trade? they are also offering to add c$!

the first one is not at all fair to you, their dec 18th chicken is just a regular rare from around 15-17 (iirc) and nothing close to the value of your side

i can't help with the second however

Please be careful with your advice. The first trade involves a UR Phoenix and that trade is not nearly as unfair as you made it out to be.

UR Phoenix trades for 1.5-2 nons.
BEG = 1.5 nons
Punk dog = 0.5 nons

For trade #1 it is fair, and depends on how you value the Phoenix and what pets you prefer.

Trade 2 is a bit beyond what I can help with while on mobile and lack of access to do some research, but from what I've noticed, the holly dog is very seasonal and while it trades for 1.5 nons, not a lot of people want it right after the holiday season. The malk dragon I think trades for 0.25-0.5 nons?
Definitely get a second opinion though lol.

[forevermine]

Should I accept this, or am I better off with my liontail?

Another one

And this one as well please

And this one

Ive been trying for 3 days to get an answer for anything Even if you can help with just one of the trades it’s super appreciated!

for the first trade !
black advent - 1 non
non tag - 1 non
non jewel - 1 non

liontail - 3 non

the trade is fair , it’s just up to you if you like it also, your liontail is a true date and it may/can go for just a bit more because of it so just to keep that in mind! but without being a true date in count it would be fair!

[~Loki~]

Should I accept this, or am I better off with my liontail?

Another one

And this one as well please

And this one

Ive been trying for 3 days to get an answer for anything Even if you can help with just one of the trades it’s super appreciated!

for the first trade !
black advent - 1 non
non tag - 1 non
non jewel - 1 non

liontail - 3 non

the trade is fair , it’s just up to you if you like it also, your liontail is a true date and it may/can go for just a bit more because of it so just to keep that in mind! but without being a true date in count it would be fair!

Thanks! Although liontails are store pets and are therefore not rereleased.

[Mocking~Jay]

Would 72 09 rares worth be to much to trade for a non balloon dog (0.5 non worth I believe)? I think it might be a bit high, but I'm not sure if people would prefer bulk, or a smaller amount of list pets. Thanks for any help, I'm pretty stuck with this.

[starpups16]

1. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103161992&userid=1011486&signature=eJTUtgMOLiGGtVqJcTzk1w

2. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103162046&userid=1011486&signature=2NDw2bjSFV-hP_ORmyMFVQ

which is a good trade? they are also offering to add c$!

[cut]

UR Phoenix trades for 1.5-2 nons.
BEG = 1.5 nons
Punk dog = 0.5 nons

For trade #1 it is fair, and depends on how you value the Phoenix and what pets you prefer.

Trade 2 is a bit beyond what I can help with while on mobile and lack of access to do some research, but from what I've noticed, the holly dog is very seasonal and while it trades for 1.5 nons, not a lot of people want it right after the holiday season. The malk dragon I think trades for 0.25-0.5 nons?
Definitely get a second opinion though lol.

Your side:
Punk 2010 stores go for 0.5 nons (Source)
Base BEG worth is 0.5 nons but can easily go for more, I’d confidently say 1.5 nons as well (Source Source)

Trade one:
Ur Phoenix regularly goes for 1.5-2 nons (Source)
Is say that depending on how you price your pets, this would be fair.

Trade 2:
UR holly will trade for 1.5 nons (Source)
Base value the malk dragon is worth roughly 1.25-2 MA but can easily go for more (Source)

C$: (I price a non at about 2000 C$ and a MA at $600)
Phoenix can easily fetch 4000 C$ (Source)
UR holly is around 2500-3000 C$
Malk Dragon is around $600 (base worth)

BEG is about 1000 C$ (base worth)
Punk Store is about 1000 C$
Hope this helps ^^

Would 72 09 rares worth be to much to trade for a non balloon dog (0.5 non worth I believe)? I think it might be a bit high, but I'm not sure if people would prefer bulk, or a smaller amount of list pets. Thanks for any help, I'm pretty stuck with this.

Based on Horrors Guide half a non will go for 50-75 2009s or 5-7 MAs. As for if someone would accept bulk, I would say yes some people would. However, I don’t doubt that it’d be easier to trade a smaller amount of list pets for the pet you’re wanting. Many people don’t like bulk and would rather have the lists, either way they will most likely end up getting traded up anyways— either you or the person that gets them haha.

[.euphoric]

okay thank you so much! all of you

[ssnowify]

thank you

[Mocking~Jay]

Thanks for the help!