The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SilverDreams7]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102129826&userid=30167&signature=wkU-P7nc9CeGIAKzR2-fjA

Is this fair? Not 100% sure on the red butterbuns worth.

The red butterbun is listed as a low main, but due to low demand seems to trade for 1 MA. The cream advent is 1 MA as well, and the nonjewel is 1 non. The UR fox trades for 1.5 nons, so they'd need to add at least another .25 nons. (although some people seem to value TDs higher, I don't think it's enough for the cream advent to make up for the gap.) You may want a second opinion though.

[Yak]

how does this look?

[AnnieDarlingxo]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102081417&userid=321906&signature=ZRiifG6DQlnig7fkVk6YNQ

Can someone please help me with this? I am not sure when it comes to items.

Please help, this is my 3rd time asking now [:

[Thegoofyfox]

how does this look?

Rats have pretty low demand, and don't trade well. I'd accept this only if you're collecting the rats

[Oragami_Cyclone]

Would a UR mountain zebra be fair to a lolita?

Help

[tiff.]

Would a UR mountain zebra be fair to a lolita?

Help

mountain zebra = 0.75-1 non
lolita = 1.5 non

unfair to lolita!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102081417&userid=321906&signature=ZRiifG6DQlnig7fkVk6YNQ

Can someone please help me with this? I am not sure when it comes to items.

Please help, this is my 3rd time asking now [:

i'd say this is fair. most of the items are really recent, except for the ink splatters from 2012 and the lollipop from the candy event a few years ago. neither of them have any special demand though!

hii! could anyone help with this trade? c:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=102153800&userid=953996&signature=5op110s39124ikaLQSE_zA

may lioness = 1 ma (6-9 '09 rares)
green vr dog = 0.5-0.75 ma (3-6 '09 rares)

i think this is unfair to the other side by maybe ~2 '09 rares

[JayJay]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102129826&userid=30167&signature=wkU-P7nc9CeGIAKzR2-fjA

Is this fair? Not 100% sure on the red butterbuns worth.

The red butterbun is listed as a low main, but due to low demand seems to trade for 1 MA. The cream advent is 1 MA as well, and the nonjewel is 1 non. The UR fox trades for 1.5 nons, so they'd need to add at least another .25 nons. (although some people seem to value TDs higher, I don't think it's enough for the cream advent to make up for the gap.) You may want a second opinion though.

Thank you so much for the response. I would love to get a second opinion as well. Is there any trade data for the TD UR Fox for more then the 1.5non? Also want to double check with the demand and the value of the pets in this trade. Thank you.

[致你 ౨ৎ]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102130432&userid=780015&signature=n9MTpoQVgpd5SaDgLnBEmQ is 2008 fair for it?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102132176&userid=780015&signature=pKVYHOL9AzD0UF6LkqvnfQ need help with this too

seeking help still

[tiff.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102129826&userid=30167&signature=wkU-P7nc9CeGIAKzR2-fjA

Is this fair? Not 100% sure on the red butterbuns worth.

The red butterbun is listed as a low main, but due to low demand seems to trade for 1 MA. The cream advent is 1 MA as well, and the nonjewel is 1 non. The UR fox trades for 1.5 nons, so they'd need to add at least another .25 nons. (although some people seem to value TDs higher, I don't think it's enough for the cream advent to make up for the gap.) You may want a second opinion though.

Thank you so much for the response. I would love to get a second opinion as well. Is there any trade data for the TD UR Fox for more then the 1.5non? Also want to double check with the demand and the value of the pets in this trade. Thank you.

i agree with what has been said, the red butterbun and cream advent both go for 1 MA, and the nonjewel = 1 non

there is *some* data that suggests the ur fox may go for 1.5-2 nons, but recently it seems to be going for 1.5 steadily

[Jaybat]

I definitely need some help with this one.