The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Raiona]

Hello! I would appreciate some advice with this trade as it's my first time trading an old rare.

Trade link

All pets being offered are on my wishlist.
I am not concerned with breed desirability - I know chickens are often low, but I like them and I am trying to collect all chickens.

On C$ value alone, using a list of values from the "how much is this worth" thread, I think it is slightly unfair, favouring them

The '09 rare being 35 C$ and the trade value being ~26.25 C$
However there's certainly something to be said for them all being on my wishlist, and several lions.

Any thoughts? Anything I'm missing?

Thank you for your time and attention.

Edit: oh this is embarrassing - Hi q-peach just above me! haha - happy to discuss via PM if you'd like, I just wanted a pulse check before diving in.

[致你 ౨ৎ]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102130432&userid=780015&signature=n9MTpoQVgpd5SaDgLnBEmQ is 2008 fair for it?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102132176&userid=780015&signature=pKVYHOL9AzD0UF6LkqvnfQ need help with this too

[screamingrainfrog]

Would I be able to swap an ur galaxy cat for ur s'mores or ur strawberry?

[fantomeadhesif]

Is 1,500 FR gems fair for these pets? trades/viewtrade.php?id=102123423&userid=901597&signature=pEvJkl-UR4Kjwy9oDY1oGQ

[LoveStruck<3]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101966807&userid=5826&signature=hwzBoYQgMvdtEvcxR45zXQ

Does this look fair? I'm so far off with rarities I have no idea if Blitzen is worth anything x.x

Any thoughts? Thanks!

[Thegoofyfox]

Hey I did a mystery grab bag is This fair?

[screamingrainfrog]

Would I be able to swap an ur galaxy cat for ur s'mores or ur strawberry or cinnabun?

[qhost]

Could anyone offer some advice on these trades? Store pets always confuse me.

One
Two

edit: I'm also curious what people think of this trade. I know the werewolf items are worth ~8 MAs all together, but how are they in terms of demand? Is it worth taking the offer?

Thanks in advance!

[heizou]

need some help on this one

[Akila]

Can someone please help me with this offer for my Bumblebee / Racecar Spider?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=102103104&userid=251473&signature=ON6RPIEXOlbdAekErc_vbQ

I got the info about it's value (4-5 MA / 0.25-0.5 N's) quite a while ago, so I'm not sure if it's still accurat.
I don't think their pets are on any list, but if I got it right, the items are pretty rare, especially as a set..?

that's correct! your spider is worth 0.25-0.5 non. the scarecrow item set is apparently worth 0.25-0.5 nons as well. the other pets on their side add up to ~2 MA, so i'd say they're overpaying.

please get a second opinion as i'm not particularly good with items and the worth i found was from one person only ^^

Thanks alot for your help!! (:


As suggested, could I have a second opinion?