The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Sweetrainbow]

I need help
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101497788&userid=179775&signature=NBWugRQSN4PGHm4GboqHaw

There are so many items. And the penguins alone are all from Christmas 2017.


Thank you

[Skiteralz]

pls really quick is this fair??? trades/viewtrade.php?id=98086254&userid=1001151&signature=yy-6gCOn2Hh8o9xw4khoNA

[qhost]

I've had these two offers on my pink skull Malk cat & I have no idea what the current demand is like, so could I please have some opinions on them?

One
Two

Also, someone sent me this item swap offer. The grass & will-o-wisps I believe are fair swaps, however I've read that the pink love gear (Valentine's 2011) can go for a 2010 uncommon, so I'm unsure this is a fair swap all together.
Thanks in avance!

[abbie.]

hi ! this is the edited version of the trade from earlier, just wanting to make sure that it’s fair for both of us since i’ve started second guessing myself ahrjrmdmd
x
thank you in advance!

[Jaax]

Hey! I Would like to check if this trade is fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101481578&userid=833950&signature=L5t8YQJvOkEdHWi9ZSqCzg

I haven’t been keeping up with list pet values so I’m not sure if my math is right or not.

Tysm for any help!

[mimitina]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101505621&userid=180216&signature=qJ4UkwBmgMhOgU-9JLDLJg it's fair or not?

[Horror]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101501491&userid=45133&signature=OaeKzJST5aD24-j8Iy7s7g

Okay, I’m terrible with older item knowledge so I did a quick search. Am I correct in thinking this is fair - possible slight overpay for me?

using the item guide the apple is worth 2 MA to 0.25 Non
the other items; illuminary bag = ~09 rare and bunnicula = 2010 rare to 09 rare

the july lioness = 2-3 MA, due to being TD it's usually rounded to 0.25 Non
Technically the apple would probably be fair, but it's worth keeping in mind items usually don't have much demand unless you're trading a collector

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101501087&userid=340814&signature=8wiSuJ5UgjIMmS6yF0Hsqw

Could I get some help on this, please? I think it should be fine but I'm having trouble finding trading data on the red striped dog. Thanks to anyone who's able to provide any clarification!

your ponies = 6 09 rares = low end of an MA

red heavy stripe = 1 MA rarity wise. After searching the forums it doesn't seem to have any available trade data, but the pets of that litter are usually very average or meh demand. If we just value it as it's worth, then this can be considered fair as ponies also aren't particularly in demand

I’m pretty sure this is is fair value wise, but I’m not sure of the demand of older VR’s versus store pets. Any insight appreciated <3

Trade Link

both stores = an 09 rare each making your side = 2 09 rares total
regular 09 vr dog = 2 09 rares

Demands pretty much just up to you. Everything in this trade (the store pets & an old VR dog) are all nice demand but none have any particular kind of demand. Some people might prefer trading store pets for other store pets, but this is mostly just up to personal preference

I'm trying to trade for the christmas tinsel lion and I know it's 1 MA, but I'm not sure if my pets add up to that, if it's overpay, underpay, if TD or RR matter for '09 rares, how much a less popular warrior cat is worth...

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101498570&userid=76973&signature=iyTsDdI9pjNeBGi9JZiPNA

your side;
rare warrior (0.5 MA, I believe this is one of the most popular of the rare warriors due to design)
everything else = about 4 09 rares + a 2011 rare (+ the 2015 rare) which is more or less 4.25 09 rares
That would be the high end of 0.5 MA or falling into 0.75 MA range, which makes your side about 1 MA (or up to 1.25)

Some people bump up TD MA pets an extra 0.5 MA, but that's not always a guarantee and usually just applies to sought after MA pets (like the t7 dog litter or list dogs in general). Considering most of your side is td as well there's a chance it might not be too big of a factor either, but this mostly just falls onto the personal preference of the user here
On the off chance they do value it slightly higher, you might need to add up to 1-3 09 rares worth

pls really quick is this fair??? trades/viewtrade.php?id=98086254&userid=1001151&signature=yy-6gCOn2Hh8o9xw4khoNA

their dog = 2 09 rares, nice demand but not the kind that gets it any notable overpay
your 2012 store = MA, or 6-9 09 rares meaning at least 6 minimum
unfair to you

I've had these two offers on my pink skull Malk cat & I have no idea what the current demand is like, so could I please have some opinions on them?

One
Two

Also, someone sent me this item swap offer. The grass & will-o-wisps I believe are fair swaps, however I've read that the pink love gear (Valentine's 2011) can go for a 2010 uncommon, so I'm unsure this is a fair swap all together.
Thanks in avance!

pink skull malk cat = 0.5 to 0.75 MA which equals 3-6 09 rares; Demand on malk pets are good but I don't believe this one has the astounding kind to where it goes for any notable overpay

first trade; their side = 4 09 rares
your side = the skull cat + an 09 rare, which leaves them offering about 3 09 rares worth for the skull cat alone. It's technically still fair as 3 09 rares can fall into 0.5 MA worth, but it's the lowest end of the worth of the cat

second trade; their side = 6 09 rares (+ the recent rares)
this is the high end of 0.75 MA, so this is fair as well


for the item trade I would get a second opinion just to be sure before accepting anything, but their reindeer item is a 2010 item and I would assume that makes it worth a 2010 uc

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101505621&userid=180216&signature=qJ4UkwBmgMhOgU-9JLDLJg it's fair or not?

using the item guide, the cupid wolf item is worth a low advent, which is about 0.5 - 0.75 MA
they have 2 09 rares worth + the parrot rat. The rat is worth an MA rarity wise, but due to rat demand it's likely valued more like 0.5 MA
0.5 MA + 2 09 rares does qualify as 0.75 MA (as it's not a full mid advent but close), so this would be fair on the higher end of your items worth

hi ! this is the edited version of the trade from earlier, just wanting to make sure that it’s fair for both of us since i’ve started second guessing myself ahrjrmdmd
x
thank you in advance!

grinners @ pink september swap,
warrior cat (0.5 MA) + white shima wolf (0.5 ma) = 1 MA together for their PPS
the 2022 rares are technically slight overpay but it's otherwise fair to both sides

Hey! I Would like to check if this trade is fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101481578&userid=833950&signature=L5t8YQJvOkEdHWi9ZSqCzg

I haven’t been keeping up with list pet values so I’m not sure if my math is right or not.

Tysm for any help!

their side; 2.75 nons solid
punk dogs = 0.5 non each = 1 non together
ur fox = 1.5 non
blood pps = 0.25 non


your side;
snowflake dogs = 0.5 MA each = 1 MA together, due to one being TD some might add an extra .5 in value for that one
seahorse store = ~2 ma
2012 stores = an ma each = 5 MA together
alpacas = MA each = 5 MA together
kitsune = ~1.5-2MA, for keeping math simple I'll use 2
rr hyena & rr twa @ ~ 1.5 MA each = 3 ma together
aussie PPS = 0.5 MA
everything else (besides the dark faced pps 2.5 09 rares or less than 0.5 MA) is an MA pet

total = 31.5 ish to 32 MA (that last 0.5 falling on the TD)
1 non equals 10-12 MA depending on pets being offered; which would make your side 2.75 nons to 3 nons
But since your side has a lot of quantity + purely nicer demand pets like old stores and MAs and list dogs, we'll use 1 non = 10 ma here, making your side the higher end @ about 3 nons, so they would need to add ~0.25 to even this out

[gecqua]

how's this? any help is appreciated!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101506452&userid=905642&signature=4XTyCM5sbdUt2-PDAWiaJQ

[AnnieDarlingxo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101506967&userid=321906&signature=r7UvILxqTFhbV26h6ueyJw

Is this fair? The items are from the 2014 Egypt Event.

[SilverDreams7]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101506967&userid=321906&signature=r7UvILxqTFhbV26h6ueyJw

Is this fair? The items are from the 2014 Egypt Event.

Unfair to you. Items usually go for an uncommon of the same year. Using the 2:1 rule, their side is about 1 and 1/2 2019 uncommons, not even close to the value of one of your items, but I'd assume they just didn't know.