The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Thegoofyfox]

Was this fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101377800&userid=1038789&signature=SzC1z78wTvXBdFzGOmhVig

[SilverDreams7]

Was this fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101377800&userid=1038789&signature=SzC1z78wTvXBdFzGOmhVig

They overpayed a lot with the 2010 rare. It would have been overpay even without the 2010 rare. You could even take off the 2014 uncommon as well it it would still be overpay.

[Thegoofyfox]

Was this fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101377800&userid=1038789&signature=SzC1z78wTvXBdFzGOmhVig

They overpayed a lot with the 2010 rare. It would have been overpay even without the 2010 rare. You could even take off the 2014 uncommon as well it it would still be overpay.

Oh okay thankyou! I was kinda confused

[sharky]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101369187&userid=1001960&signature=QBo3aYX2KKS_FTQL2ytEBQ

Help? This is really complicated for my tiny brain ;-;

[Moiraine]

Is this fair? Sorry for the formatting, I'm on mobile-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101375335&userid=39854&signature=3qV9Yv63XCvTSSCIU735eg

Would still appreciate an answer on this, I don't want to keep the other person waiting indefinitely when they've been patient already!

[Equinox...]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101377789&userid=963181&signature=Y7KgoAYQ94y-QNUopAP_BQ

Please help!

[rats <3]

Hi guys! Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101352011&userid=22963&signature=84oZiz4JoQ4ONcp_O8rDQA

Thank you in advance for any advice! <3

[aryn <3]

a

[CultOfKinitoAndJax]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101261230&userid=1004512&signature=0_JXSEcqkwXj_mA_FA3YMw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101319972&userid=1004512&signature=F82a4D1dbRAXbGzBr1bcBQ

fair? i dont use items


trades/viewtrade.php?id=101334324&userid=1004512&signature=Re3f4Yz1MlIVGWr5OfODbQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101382584&userid=1004512&signature=4bGO3BxvPH4e_HCpx67B_g

and these?

[NightmareSystem]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101374909&userid=376053&signature=tucxzgiXzN4ekzMzPOMRFA

I am trying to figure out if this balanced out, for educational purposes

————————
I believe the top overpaid by a small bit, being that the baby duck was unneeded. But Lions have demand, so that overpay covers the demand for the lions imo.

Bottom Trade:
2022 common x 2 = 2022 uncommon or a 2021 common

2022 uncommon is a 2021 common

2021comm + 2021comm = 2021uncomm

——-
My reasoning example if you have two uncommons from the same year they usually equal a rare if the 2:1 is followed, so I assume it would be the same for the other rarities.
2022r 2022r | 2022un 2022un | 2022c 2022c
2021r ~~~~~~~~ 2021un ~~~~~~~~~ 2021c

——
Edit: In C$

Top
2021un = 0.50C$
2022c = 0.125C$
T= 0.625C$
——
Bottom
2022un = 0.25C$
2022c = 0.125C$
2022c = 0.125C$
T= 0.50C$

Phew, I do admit that this is extremely difficult to follow 😅

What I am understanding, using 2022 year as an example, if I trade 2 commons for 1 uncommon it would be as fair as if I traded 2 uncommons for 1 rare?

Separate question, using the years 2022 and 2013 as an example. Would the same apply if I traded 2 2013 commons for 1 2022 uncommon or would the value bump the 2022 up to a rare because of the year??