The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Androys]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000243&userid=989864&signature=fs2fliBXdi6f0nP4me4rug

[winx]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000243&userid=989864&signature=fs2fliBXdi6f0nP4me4rug

Witchdoctor Set - 2012 Halloween. I value each piece as a 2012 uncommon. This could go two (+ a third if you value them as rare each) ways depending on how you value uncommons to rares.

If you believe 4 uncommons = 1 rare, then this is the math below.
4 2012 uncommons = 1 2012 rare.
They are offering...
1 2011 rare --> 2 2012 rares. It would make it fair + some overpay.

If you believe 2 uncommons = 1 rare, then this is the math below.
4 2012 uncommons = 2 2012 rares.
They are offering...
1 2011 rare --> 2 2012 rares. It would make it fair + some overpay.

If you value each piece as a 2012 rare each, then this would be unfair to you.

Hopefully this provides a good set of options to work from based on your own personal preferences. (:

[Ein.]

Thanks, I have another one, im pretty sure the pets themselves are fair as a swap but don't know about the items (assuming the C$ are meant to be for the items themselves)x

[da,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101001134&userid=652611&signature=riSIHIJzqm8ZdXnMnuqc8g
Any assistance? Tyvm!
-DA

[winx]

Thanks, I have another one, im pretty sure the pets themselves are fair as a swap but don't know about the items (assuming the C$ are meant to be for the items themselves)x

Red Fronted Holly - 1 MA
Light Gray Spotted Husky - 1 MA

Dogs are a fair swap rarity-wise.

Angel Costume - 2011 Halloween. 2011 uncommon to rare.
Leather Wristband - June 2012. 2012 uncommon to rare.
Deep Space BG & Nebulae BG - 2015 CS Birthday. 2015 uncommon each.
Dogwood Necklace & Tulip Ear Clip - 2015 Easter. 2015 un/common each.
Wild Wig - 2017 Lost City Event. 2017 uncommon.

Using the C$ guide again for calculations...
[these are values I chose based on how I would value the items, so they can be changed around if you value an item higher/lower]
20-25 (Angel, 2011 rare) + 8-9 (Wristband, 2012 unc) + 4-5 + 4-5 (backgrounds, 2015 unc) + 4-5 + 4-5 (Necklace/Clip, 2015 unc) + 2 (wig, 2017 unc) =
46-56 C$

[numbers by themselves for easy swapping of values: 20-25 + 8-9 + 4-5 + 4-5 + 4-5 + 4-5 + 2 ]

You can change the values above if you have your own personal C$ guide you work from.

60 C$ seems fair for the items. Please get a second opinion though if you're unsure.

[SkeletonHug]

Is this fair? I feel like this is a lot of overpay on their side?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100997524&userid=631866&signature=uS06Pbx_B3wrqWy3vlhjmQ

[Zeena]

Thanks, I have another one, im pretty sure the pets themselves are fair as a swap but don't know about the items (assuming the C$ are meant to be for the items themselves)x

the red fronted holly used to be lower on the list but fronm the looks of it it is stable 1 MA now - https://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/search.php?keywords=red+fronted&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
you just need to consider if you are interested in selling the items for C$

Edit:

Is this fair? I feel like this is a lot of overpay on their side?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100997524&userid=631866&signature=uS06Pbx_B3wrqWy3vlhjmQ

yes 2010 rare would be worth more than the pets on your side

[Arcanine Luver]

hello,
do you guys think this trade is fair?(:

[SkeletonHug]

Is this fair? I feel like this is a lot of overpay on their side?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100997524&userid=631866&signature=uS06Pbx_B3wrqWy3vlhjmQ

yes 2010 rare would be worth more than the pets on your side

That's what I was thinking?? Thank you !

[Wysterinka]

hello,
do you guys think this trade is fair?(:

green tox is between .25 - .5 non depends where you value it but since it's not TD I would say more to the lower side, 2012 somewhat go for 1 MA each and so does the T7 dog and corgi
nonjewel seems to be getting steady 1 non