The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SilverDreams7]

I know this trade was canceled, but could I get some opinions on it? I've been giving a couple of commons (or event swaps) or a recent/couple years old 'common' - uncommon for the other event pets, including Cthulhu. And they have been accepted. I understand people value pets differently and that's fine, I'm just genuinely curious if this was an actual unfair trade? I may be an older player, but I've never got the logistics of trading very well.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100932017&userid=6076&signature=mP4h3M9LHgyNTrnYz5iTUg
Thanks for any help, I fully appreciate it.

Most people I've seen will double a pet's value with each year, so the 2016 rare would be worth 64 2022 rares, so you were overpaying quite a bit. I'd just assume that maybe they liked their pets more, they don't value pets the same way, or they just don't trade unknown rarities.

[luckydraw]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100939282&userid=816125&signature=xoSbE2un8vFwFjKsxZ5bNQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100939317&userid=816125&signature=W1eliDqz9VkjCE_kqysP6Q

Are either of these trades fair for both me and the person on the other side? I wasn’t great with list pet trades before they disbanded the list and I’m even worse now that it’s disbanded. Thank you in advance to anyone who helps!

[Loui.]

Is anyone good with items? I have absolutely no idea what they’re worth

item trade


Also, I have zero knowledge left on rarity trades. Especially since the lists are "gone" or were remade.

rarity trade


Thank you in advance! <3

[EditPink]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100935878&userid=902320&signature=jcwKDczykxPG2Q9G4_7yzQ


trades/viewtrade.php?id=100941630&userid=902320&signature=Vw-H6Jk-NCV9J3Dr_M9Fkw

Thanks for any help

[oluvia]

1 & 2

hiya! are these fair? thank u!

[M1D]

any help on this? please and thank you in advance! (mainly just need help on the fairness for the '13 store pet)

[Shirlyn]

I'm a bit unsure if this trade is quite fair.
I know that Store Pets from 2021 are going for about a (late) rare 2010.
But the rest seems a bit over it beside the 3 Store pets for the 3 2010 Rares ^^'
I took this - Rares across years as a reference but still really unsure since those are event pets on their side.
Thanks for any opinion in this !

[MissDream]

Some help please? Thanks

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100941658&userid=587322&signature=ywew7AuChguCvJkqhnxG4Q

[Ein.]

Can I get an opinion on this trade?

I would call that overpay on their end.

Alright thanks can I have one more opinion

Edit: this too please I'm outdated on list stuff
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100938904&userid=652660&signature=jz3DnK4vKg-D8o7F8gXHxA

[flooxii]

Any help? I don't really want to accept but Idkkkk