The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Christmas Spirit]

Hello, I'm new and wondering if this trade is fair?

[JeffSatur'sHusband]

I'm not sure if there is a specific demand on the pet on my side so i just wanted to make sure this was fair before i accepted!
Here
Any help is appreciated! Thanks!

[Riley ♥]

Hello, I'm new and wondering if this trade is fair?

Very unfair to you, they would need hundreds of 2021 commons in order to equal a 2011 uncommon if you use the 2:1 ratio (2 commons = 1 uncommon of the same year). Trading like this with large gaps in years doesn't really work all that well, the best either side can do is just make a trade for what looks right. Your side doesn't have any special demand, but lots of people see cats as being "worth more" or "more desirable" than rats.

[Riley ♥]

I'm not sure if there is a specific demand on the pet on my side so i just wanted to make sure this was fair before i accepted!
Here
Any help is appreciated! Thanks!

The PPS pets of store sets usually go for a little bit more than the rest of the set due to demand. There isn't much trade data on this pet, so if you do trade the PPS Unicorn, I recommend you post it on the Successful Trades Thread!

I would personally say that this trade is fair to make up for the slightly higher demand of the PPS.

[Ein.]

Can I get an opinion on this trade?

[miraikuriyama]

what are the pets on their side worth? i'm most likely not accepting solely because i'd like something else but i'd like to know their worth and if it's fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100935475&userid=151936&signature=dLColZUCm8ad406dcB3eJg

[Guardian85]

Can I get an opinion on this trade?

I would call that overpay on their end.

[Ein.]

Can I get an opinion on this trade?

I would call that overpay on their end.

Alright thanks can I have one more opinion

Edit: this too please I'm outdated on list stuff
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100938904&userid=652660&signature=jz3DnK4vKg-D8o7F8gXHxA

[miskit]

asking for some item trading advice! no idea what these older items are worth

[CalicoWolf]

I know this trade was canceled, but could I get some opinions on it? I've been giving a couple of commons (or event swaps) or a recent/couple years old 'common' - uncommon for the other event pets, including Cthulhu. And they have been accepted. I understand people value pets differently and that's fine, I'm just genuinely curious if this was an actual unfair trade? I may be an older player, but I've never got the logistics of trading very well.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100932017&userid=6076&signature=mP4h3M9LHgyNTrnYz5iTUg
Thanks for any help, I fully appreciate it.