The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[MortalLove17]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99835685&userid=403860&signature=N-5dGTWbhbNc_Mo9pmd-pQ

Help please!
The item is a current dreamie of mine, but I don't want to be cheated out of a rare either.

[Pyca]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99835685&userid=403860&signature=N-5dGTWbhbNc_Mo9pmd-pQ

Help please!
The item is a current dreamie of mine, but I don't want to be cheated out of a rare either.

according to this it's worth a mid/late 09 rare. So the horse is an underpay technically. If this is a dreamie item, go for it!

[MortalLove17]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99835685&userid=403860&signature=N-5dGTWbhbNc_Mo9pmd-pQ

Help please!
The item is a current dreamie of mine, but I don't want to be cheated out of a rare either.

according to this it's worth a mid/late 09 rare. So the horse is an underpay technically. If this is a dreamie item, go for it!

Thank you!

[Cyll]

Can anyone help with the math on this one?

It’s a lot of pets but I’m legitimately not sure if it’s considered overpay or not due to the age gap between the items and a good chunk of the pets.

[bathory_lord]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99838392&userid=994841&signature=n6S7yzwNeacvGk-V4TB8UA

is this fair?

[Deerdancer]

Is this fair? Involves items.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99831204&userid=203847&signature=Fo_caiTe-XnKCqQ40G0_bw

[Aleigh]

How much would they need to add to make this fair?

Personally valuing my Flamingo at 2.5 nons for reference!

[Spinda]

Help please. They say malk are in high demand. They said about 2 rares from years before the year of their malk, or 1 of the same year, now when I offered the rare horse on their WL they're now throwing demands at me and want a couple more pets out of me. I'm not saying this person is doing this but I feel like I'm being taken advantage of or scammed of slight inflation of the pet, I could be wrong but I seriously want help.

Because It's something I want as I have a goal to get all pets that are skeleton/skull/bone theme and I stated that and now I feel like they changed it because it's something I want so now throwing demands at me.

So please help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99829478&userid=958822&signature=MjL-wC2Ybxro8RB2kPsu2A

[bugbaby]

Help please. They say malk are in high demand. They said about 2 rares from years before the year of their malk, or 1 of the same year, now when I offered the rare horse on their WL they're now throwing demands at me and want a couple more pets out of me. I'm not saying this person is doing this but I feel like I'm being taken advantage of or scammed of slight inflation of the pet, I could be wrong but I seriously want help.

Because It's something I want as I have a goal to get all pets that are skeleton/skull/bone theme and I stated that and now I feel like they changed it because it's something I want so now throwing demands at me.

So please help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99829478&userid=958822&signature=MjL-wC2Ybxro8RB2kPsu2A

malk pets on their own don't have ridiculously high demand but it's there, and combined with the fact that horses tend to be lower demand, i can see some of their reasoning. however, rarity-wise, you're overpaying as without factoring in demand, the horse would be a fair swap for the wolf

[Prince Endymion]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99839571&userid=417321&signature=nv8VDAvg1t8g7_aUg6gwSw

Can someone tell me if this is fair or not...? I see some of these are December 18ths I don't know the true C$ value of. I'm not looking for options of pets to add to their side, I only look for C$. Also if you can tell me which pets would add up to about that amount if not the whole trade, that would be incredible. Thank you! 💙