The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[~{Lazarus}~]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99810049&userid=439840&signature=FLRL97i7GTG46wejCx0Jkg

[ryuuhou]

is this fair? im out of the loop with trades ,,, trades/viewtrade.php?id=99802940&userid=464633&signature=bmj-90tEkJEPJpmXGNfmUQ

[Vanrouge]

I haven't traded properly at all in a good year or so so just wondering if this would be a fair trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99832570&userid=429963&signature=e3wPJpeWMNcK9zrN0s9hkA
Thank you to anyone who helps!

[GoldieDoggy]

Would this be a fair trade? trades/viewtrade.php?id=99800599&userid=949727&signature=nErrTlcD3VQC_hCi7646Yw

I'm still figuring out demand/worth for things on CS, so any help is appreciated!
Reposting this to get a second opinion to make sure!

[Leikindasuxkz]

Any help? Please and thanks!

[sapphirelion]

Any help? Please and thanks!

For the most part the uncommons are all equal (they are all from the same year, though some are further than the 3 months apart so that's a little off).

"A 2017 rare/very rare is worth around 8-10C$"
Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3915876#p121023871

So just a rare equals 8-9c$ (any pet from January- June of that year being worth 9c$; any pet from July-December of that year being worth 8c$).

You have 2 from the first equaling 9c$ each and one from the second equaling 8c$.
9+9+8= 26c$

This is very unfair to you! Even if they were trying to even out the uncommons, there is no way they'd need to take off that much c$

[boodles]

Would this be a fair trade? trades/viewtrade.php?id=99800599&userid=949727&signature=nErrTlcD3VQC_hCi7646Yw

I'm still figuring out demand/worth for things on CS, so any help is appreciated!
Reposting this to get a second opinion to make sure!

Realistically unfair to them- the banana is typically valued at 1 non and the sorbet is 0.5 nons. The rares don’t make up much difference. I will say that finding someone to pay a non for a banana is near impossible so in terms of demand, you’ll have a much easier time trading the sorbet.

[oluvia]

Is this fair !?

can i get some more opinions on this? thank you!

[Spinda]

Help please. They say malk are in high demand. They said about 2 rares from years before the year of their malk, or 1 of the same year, now when I offered the rare horse on their WL they're now throwing demands at me and want a couple more pets out of me. I'm not saying this person is doing this but I feel like I'm being taken advantage of or scammed of slight inflation of the pet, I could be wrong but I seriously want help.

Because It's something I want as I have a goal to get all pets that are skeleton/skull/bone theme and I stated that and now I feel like they changed it because it's something I want so now throwing demands at me.

So please help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99829478&userid=958822&signature=MjL-wC2Ybxro8RB2kPsu2A

[Deerdancer]

Is this fair? Involves items.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99831204&userid=203847&signature=Fo_caiTe-XnKCqQ40G0_bw