The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[never_gone_]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99816047&userid=327628&signature=N3rSz1I6teeWPJBHkGq1KQ

Hello! I just received this trade and wanted some insight. They’re offering a 2009 VR malk horse for my Advent list Valentine’s Day PPS dog (originally 2009, dated 2021 re-release). I know mine is a list, but I’m not very experienced with list trades. I imagine I should add more to their side???

[sharky]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99817027&userid=1001960&signature=R91aWLrSi9poMr26HkFICg

Is this trade fair? I'm not really up to date with store pet value. Thanks!

[MiaShuji]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99817027&userid=1001960&signature=R91aWLrSi9poMr26HkFICg

Is this trade fair? I'm not really up to date with store pet value. Thanks!

2020 store pets are worth an 09 rare.... The 2010 rule counts for 2022 and 2021

[sharky]

from what ive been told, a recent rare store pet is worth about a 2010 rare,
so yes it is fair/theyre overpaying a little by the commons/uncommons, but there is also demand to account for (which i am not in tune with).

would get a second opinion

2020 store pets are worth an 09 rare.... The 2010 rule counts for 2022 and 2021

Thank you both

[spacemilk]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99816973&userid=960578&signature=ISqbe0yrSK0ge7f06PyaoQ
yo, does this look good?

[Arcanine Luver]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99816973&userid=960578&signature=ISqbe0yrSK0ge7f06PyaoQ
yo, does this look good?

the Null PPS is a high october list worth 0.5 MA which can normally fetch 150 C$!!
i would not take this!

[tatilucia]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99815667&userid=74655&signature=toa0ejwWB5LNt4VNIlM2kQ

Help? all items cost 80C$, I don't know the value of this pet...

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99815667&userid=74655&signature=toa0ejwWB5LNt4VNIlM2kQ

Help? all items cost 80C$, I don't know the value of this pet...

Unfair to you considerably in my opinion.
Going off the *C$ guide here… A 2014 rare/very rare is worth around 15-18C$.
I’ve personally spent around 20-25 C$ each for the Halloween chickens. You could definitely find a better deal for it elsewhere.

* Not everyone follows the C$ guide, but it at least gives a basis/estimate of values to work off of. Using the ballpark estimates, one can work up or down from the initial values to find a fair price for individual pets. *

[Reirin]

hello there! I’m not great with current pet rarities and demand, so I’m not sure about this trade I’ve received. any help would be much appreciated! thanks in advance 💕

[winx]

hello there! I’m not great with current pet rarities and demand, so I’m not sure about this trade I’ve received. any help would be much appreciated! thanks in advance 💕

Unfair to you.
Your Black Kitsune is worth around 1-2+ MA - trade data here. Typically pushes to the higher end of 1.5-2 MAs.

They are offering the Red Panda GUPPS. It turned very rare in January 2019, making it worth the three month rule or 2 ‘09 rares.
They are also offering a 2011 rare. Using 2:1 rule, 1 2011 rare —> 0.5 2010 rare —> 0.25 2009 rare.
In total, their side is worth ~2.25 ‘09 rares, not including any additional demand.

Your side of 1-2 MAs is considerably more.
For reference: 1 MA = 6-9 09 Rares