The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[~NuggieNugg~]

Hi, would this be fair?

The trade involves items, so I'm not sure if it's fair or not.

Thank you!

[zealouss]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99749516&userid=1002109&signature=oZTVED_OnISTfig0Lwmnhg

Hii is this fair? thank you in advance!
*item trade*

[Toxique]

Is this fair?

[SarcasticLoner]

Notoriously bad at determining fairness of trades containing items...

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99794002&userid=381069&signature=WF1hy0H21Nh5buNLjwEWug

Anyone able to give their opinion?

[Forever Lost]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99777525&userid=192057&signature=mr9A0Sprrj9g4KIA6mhVkw

There’s a lot going on here. 148 pets and 100C$ for my 29 pets and 5 items. Is it fair?

I’m not sure with demand what the rerelease pets on your side are worth, but I hope this will help someone else to finish helping you ❤️

Their side:
2x 2009 rares
2x 2016 rares
5x 2017 rares
3x 2018 rares
2x 2019 rares
30x 2020 uncommons
18x 2020 commons
9x 2020 very commons
19x 2021 uncommons
43x 2021 commons
11x 2021 very commons
5x 2022 commons
100c$

Your side:
Rerelease pets that are probably worth more than when they released (but I’d double check because I’m not 100% sure that all have demand) :
2014 very rare is actually from November 2008
2015 very rare is actually from November 2008
2016 very rare is actually from September 2009

1x 2010 rare
2x 2012 rares
2x 2012 uncommons
2x 2013 uncommons
1x 2013 common
2x 2014 rares
6x 2014 uncommons
1x 2014 common
3x 2015 rares
2x 2015 uncommons
1x 2015 common
3x 2022 unknown rarities (generally considered an uncommon until given a rarity)

(Items are worth a common or uncommon from the year they released, I personally value them at an uncommon so that’s what I’ll use here)
Animal egg 36 - 2013 uncommon
Animal egg 37 - 2013 uncommon
Bandana - 2013 uncommon
Button eyes - 2013 uncommon
Animal egg 40 - 2014 uncommon
———————————————————————————
I use the 2:1 rule for year and rarity differences (2 uncommons = 1 rare from the same year ; 2 2022 rares= 1 2021 rare) so I’m going to remove some pets from each side doing this:

Removing (simple conversions first):
Their side = Your side
4x 2022 commons = 2x 2022 unknown rarities
1x 2021 common = 1x 2022 unknown rarity
2x 2016 rares = 1 2015 rare
Removing (more complex):
Their side = Your side
remaining 2022, 2021, & 2020 pets = about 2 2015 uncommons (technically it’s 1.96 2015 uncommons)
4 2017 rares = 1 2015 rare

New sides (placing the items as the year/rarity worth in this list and on to make it easier to see):
Their side:
2x 2009 rares
1x 2017 rares
3x 2018 rares
2x 2019 rares
100c$

your side:
*2x 2008 very rares
*2009 very rare
2x 2012 rares
2x 2012 uncommons
6x 2013 uncommons
1x 2013 common
2x 2014 rares
7x 2014 uncommons
1x 2014 common
1x 2015 rares
1x 2015 common

Sorry I couldn’t narrow it down much further without knowing the full worth of the rereleases, but I hope this will at least partially help ❤️

Thank you. I’ll still need more help with it, but this does help.

[dia_dartenheit]

is it fair?
i know all the other pets are a huge underpaying, but i'm wondering about the store giraffe.

[Toxique]

is it fair?
i know all the other pets are a huge underpaying, but i'm wondering about the store giraffe.

Unfair to the nick dog considering the giraffe. A 2021 store pet is worth a late 2010 rare and as far as I've seen only the pps giraffe has slightly higher demand than the others ^^

[dia_dartenheit]

is it fair?
i know all the other pets are a huge underpaying, but i'm wondering about the store giraffe.

Unfair to the nick dog considering the giraffe. A 2021 store pet is worth a late 2010 rare and as far as I've seen only the pps giraffe has slightly higher demand than the others ^^

thank you, this part about 2021 store pet = late 2010 rare is very helpful!

[oluvia]

is this fair?

[Vilhelm]

i am aware that this is fair, valuing ur aussie at a non, but still looking for a bit of advice!
here

i havent had much experience with the ur aussie/cookie dog in a bit, so i dont recall how easy it is to trade, not to mention the bulk being asked of on my end haha