The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[QuietRebel]

Is this fair?
Trade

[da,]

trade : was this fair?

IMO quite over. UR pumpkin is worth 2 nons. The yellow toxic, gearback and C$ would be .5 nons each, or 1.5 nons total. The UR Mint horse can go for between .5-1 nons, so depending on what you value the horse at thats already 2-2.5 nons. The rest of the pets probably add up to another .5-1 nons, totaling your side at 2.5-3.5 nons.

[Rbpuppy]

Thoughts on this one? I do love the yellow toxic c:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99717022&userid=42960&signature=x0hxRiyRCJp9E7h6ZQNhiQ

[Cyll]

Trade

Not great with math. The item is from Christmas 2009 and is a Malk item if that matters. I’ve been told event items typically go for an uncommon from their release year but I want to see if this one is worth more due to age.

[♥HazelNightmare]

Thoughts on this one? I do love the yellow toxic c:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99717022&userid=42960&signature=x0hxRiyRCJp9E7h6ZQNhiQ

With the yellow toxic being true date it goes for about .75- 1 non , the bunny suit is another 2 MA .
Your RR Black Advent is 1 non.
It’s a decent offer imo and I personally would consider because of the true date of the toxic, but it’s up to you which you like more .

Trade

Not great with math. The item is from Christmas 2009 and is a Malk item if that matters. I’ve been told event items typically go for an uncommon from their release year but I want to see if this one is worth more due to age.

While most items are valued at an uncommon of their release year the same doesn’t apply to older items, certain event items, retired store items ect. Always good to double check here if you are unsure of the items worth like you did .

The horse figurines go for a 09 rare min so this trade offer would be unfair to you .

[♥HazelNightmare]

trade : was this fair?

IMO quite over. UR pumpkin is worth 2 nons. The yellow toxic, gearback and C$ would be .5 nons each, or 1.5 nons total. The UR Mint horse can go for between .5-1 nons, so depending on what you value the horse at thats already 2-2.5 nons. The rest of the pets probably add up to another .5-1 nons, totaling your side at 2.5-3.5 nons.

I agree that your side is over.

Pumpkin pie 1.5-2 , usually lower end as of recently

Mint Tess horse .5 max
Gearback tribal .25
Rr yellow toxic .5

Cake dog 2 Ma
2012 stores x 2= 2 Ma
2011 store gryphon 2 Ma
2013 store Chimera and Phoenix .5 x2= 1 Ma possibly 2
TD purple heart husky 2 MA
=10 MA = 1 Non

Plus 2009 Very rare and C$

1000 c$

[Redpanda]

thoughts on this guy?

ty!

[eufemia]

posted this yesterday but not sure
if anyone replied as i forgot abt it, so any help would be appreciated!

[Athena Waters]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99748646&userid=1025686&signature=-FLnbuyXQwmM4XYvth95fg


Is this fair

Still need help

[♥HazelNightmare]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99748646&userid=1025686&signature=-FLnbuyXQwmM4XYvth95fg


Is this fair

Still need help

It’s already been canceled I see but it is very unfair to the top. Just one of the 2011 uncommon Malk owls would have been over for your side