The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Genba]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99507906&userid=320360&signature=3uD4lWlepeaF2HoLd310Og

I know the TD goes for 1 MA, but how about the rerelease?

[QuietRebel]

Is this fair?
Trade

[DisneyLuv]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99506306&userid=1024045&signature=XpRpyAGS1ryT43nj08PlDw

hi! could I have some help with this please? ty!!

This depends on what matters to you. If dates matter, it’s unfair to them because their oldest pet is 2016 and your pet is 2021. If rarity matters more, it’s unfair to you, because they’re offering only two very commons and one common for your pet. I have also seen some demand going around for that specific litter, so to some users, it’s subject to slight overpay.
I guess what I’m saying is that preference is up to you, and depending on what you value more, it can be considered fair or unfair for either party.

[Quackers <3]

How does this look? I am terrible when it comes to CS

Thanks!

[DisneyLuv]

Needing some help with these trades!

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=99507788&userid=1031353&signature=y9mi_8krTkeSwWMRxTcLWA

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=99507787&userid=1031353&signature=YmlUxxSgE6qnpY0YuNgphA

3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=99488254&userid=1031353&signature=q8B1TsLMZO5aXAtfqcusKg

4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=99462310&userid=1031353&signature=RnGw5uwgXWtBSyGUCG0RUQ

5. trades/viewtrade.php?id=99284082&userid=1031353&signature=qoEvQk4M4KZ4kMxZQDe8vA

1. Unfair to them if dates matter. They’re offering pets from 2010 and 2011 for a bunch of pets from 2022. I will point out however that rats don’t tend to trade well, and demand is very limited from user to user. Rabbits are a more popular species, and likely will trade better. But preference is up to you. If you want to make it more fair, you’ll need to add some older pets.

2. Very unfair to you. They’re offering pets that are newer and have no demand for your older malk owl that does come with demand. I’d ask them to add, or I’d reject.

3. This is unfair to you, if rarity matters. The pets they’re offering add up to a ‘20 uncommon and a ‘21 uncommon, which wouldn’t be a fair trade for a 2022 rare, even if their pets are slightly older. If they added another ‘21 uncommon and took away their ‘20 uncommon, it would be a fairer swap.

4. This could be made fair. Their side is currently equivalent to a ‘21 rare and a ‘21 uncommon. If they added another ‘21 uncommon, it would be a fair swap for the rabbit alone. If they want your other two pets, they’ll need to add another ‘22 uncommon and a ‘22 common.

5. Slightly unfair to them. Their side is equivalent to a ‘14 rare plus a ‘16 common. If they’re okay with swapping the equivalent of a ‘14 rare for your ‘16 rare, then preference is just up to you.

[DisneyLuv]

can i get opinions on this trade?
thanks in advance!!

This depends on how you value the card dog. Trade data suggests that it usually trades for .5 MA’s or 3-4 ‘09 rares, but with demand can sometimes reach 1 MA or 6-9 ‘09 rares depending on the user.
The dog you have is worth 1 MA, which is 6-9 ‘09 rares.
If you value the card dog at its base value, then I’d say they need to add another 3-4 ‘09 rares. Otherwise, it can be an even swap.

[DisneyLuv]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99507906&userid=320360&signature=3uD4lWlepeaF2HoLd310Og

I know the TD goes for 1 MA, but how about the rerelease?

Rereleases are worth the exact same. Some users do not value them the same, but it is still worth 1 MA even as a rerelease. It would make this trade wildly unfair to you.

[DisneyLuv]

Is this fair?
Trade

Even with all of the rare’s they’re asking for from you, it would be unfair to them. Their oldest rare dates to 2010, and your oldest dates to 2016. If they’re okay with trading you their older pets for your newer pets, than preference is up to both of you. But if you wanted to make it fair, you’d have to throw in a number of older pets. Sometimes editing the trade down helps.

[DisneyLuv]

How does this look? I am terrible when it comes to CS

Thanks!

It’s a pretty good offer. The Aussie dog i’d value towards the higher end, because it does have some demand. The deer store set is worth 1 ‘09 rare altogether at this time.
The low end offer would be 90 C$ and the high end 110 C$. You’d be getting a tad bit more bang for your buck if you accepted, in terms of C$ worth. Otherwise, you can edit and bring it down to a value you’re more comfortable with.

[FriedApplePie]

Thank you for help with the previous trades! I got another

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99497711&userid=44211&signature=UFH1fzVvW2Fqbarm3OO7KA