The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[DisneyLuv]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99494157&userid=825141&signature=8_Z6dGyhISI-Cy0OrTcF8w wondering how this trade is?
And this
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99496046&userid=825141&signature=WZz9vWVEYxQri25DmoBWzA

I can answer the first one for now, as I don’t have the time to math out the second one.

Your store pet is worth 2 ‘09 rares, and their valentines malk horse is worth 4 ‘09 rare’s. You’d have to add to make it fair for them.

[DisneyLuv]

Needing opinions!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99501467&userid=1031353&signature=MrXXceleshkyKrhI-DY-4w

Unfair to them. All of the pets they’re offering are from 2012, and none of the pets on your side add up to the same worth. You’d have to throw in some ‘12 uncommons or about five ‘13 uncommons to make it fair for them.

[Amani_Ink]

Trying to collect bunnies is hard but I also don't wanna be unfair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99501613&userid=1035926&signature=1qvdLmiDtM_mrHr8hXk-dw

[DisneyLuv]

Trying to collect bunnies is hard but I also don't wanna be unfair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99501613&userid=1035926&signature=1qvdLmiDtM_mrHr8hXk-dw

If they value the PPS duck more than the rabbit, than that’s okay. Otherwise, if you’d like to make it fair, you’ll have to add in an uncommon from 2020 or two 2021 uncommons.

[sparklydog]

Hiya! Any advice on this one? I'm not sure how old the offered rares are, so I don't know what exactly to offer back to make it fair

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99499454&userid=259122&signature=YrBILaEY2FjrZiMOFGq8lw

[siffrin.]

hello hello! is this trade fair? c: if it isn't, i would love to know why if possible! thank you in advance!

[FriedApplePie]

Thank you for help with the previous trades! I got another

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99497711&userid=44211&signature=UFH1fzVvW2Fqbarm3OO7KA

[valkyrie,,]

Hiya! Any advice on this one? I'm not sure how old the offered rares are, so I don't know what exactly to offer back to make it fair

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99499454&userid=259122&signature=YrBILaEY2FjrZiMOFGq8lw

their black/yellow dog is from sept '10, and their other dog is from july '11. you would need to add significantly to make it fair.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99494157&userid=825141&signature=8_Z6dGyhISI-Cy0OrTcF8w wondering how this trade is?
And this
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99496046&userid=825141&signature=WZz9vWVEYxQri25DmoBWzA

I can answer the first one for now, as I don’t have the time to math out the second one.

Your store pet is worth 2 ‘09 rares, and their valentines malk horse is worth 4 ‘09 rare’s. You’d have to add to make it fair for them.

their store is commonly worth .5ma and the malk horse is a high october list so is also worth .5ma, i would consider this fair.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99474633&userid=1016830&signature=Eb057pfxW8UMUWLajaSs0A
could i get some help? please pm

'12 store pets are worth a late '10r, this is fair.

- trades/viewtrade.php?id=99492452&userid=746312&signature=T4nkSJ-p7zJQs57B9JNMew

How is this trade? I know the "rares list" has been discontinued but I know some people still use it as a guide for trading. Please feel free to message me or comment here! Thankyou

your fairy foxes are worth an '09r each, maybe a little more, with the pps being generally worth 2-3 or ~.5ma due to popularity. their bone pps is worth 1ma. with 1 ma = 6-9 '09r and your pets totaling around ~5-6 '09r, i would consider this fair, just personal preference of which pets you would prefer :)

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99490173&userid=780015&signature=MCPHp6-dVuGR0y6I51Zh1A this please

they are overpaying as their uc is from '11, which would be worth 2 '11c. your pets are much older so this would be unfair to them.

Help, thanks!


trades/viewtrade.php?id=99460680&userid=1022867&signature=j7hs98I5QDB_sC9q15eDAw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98790333&userid=1022867&signature=zwbPZP33HF1vihEyRqjyuA

I really need the answers

I really need the answers ASAP, please help

first trade;
their side;
'17 store = '09r per = 2 '09r
'19 store = '10r per = 8 '10r = 4 '09r (may fetch more due to lion popularity, strictly using rarities for calculation purposes)
'22 store = '11r per = 3 '11r = 1 '10r + 1 '11r
total = 7 '09r + 1 '11r (again strictly rarity)

your side;
brown cookie = 1ma
with 1ma = 6-9 '09r this would technically be fair, but on the lower end. t7 dogs commonly fetch the higher end.

second trade;
their side;
'15 manticore = .5ma (~3-4 '09r)
'17 store = 1 '09r by rarity, but very popular so can definitely fetch more (for math i'll use 2 '09r)
2 griffons = each worth 1 '09r strictly rarity wise but commonly fetch more (for math i'll use 2 '09r)
'21 store = 1 '10r
strictly value/rarity wise = 6-7 '09r
with demand (not 100% accurate, but a decent estimate) = 8-9 '09r

your side;
'21 store = 1 '10r per = 3 '10r = 1 '09r + 1 '10r
brown cookie = 1ma
honestly this trade all depends on your personal value of their store pets. demand plays a huge part in the value of '17 stores specifically since those sets are very popular. there is no steady demand-based worth that i have noticed while combing through multiple threads (fair trade, successful vr/omgsr trades, etc). in c$ trades, gryphons can fetch around 1-2 '09r worth. i believe these were also already answered on pg 753.

@DisneyLuv in response to pg. 764, i think you're using the 4:1 rule instead of the 2:1 rule. it's not wrong at all, it's just that most people don't use it. check out this explanation here of the 2:1 rule. it explains that 1 '09vr = 2 '09r = 4 '10r, simplified for what was addressed, 2 '09r = 4 '10r, or 1 '09r = 2 '10r. 2 '10r does also = 1 '10vr like you said, but this also means that 1 '10vr would = 1 '09r (easier to explain if you split the '10vr into 2 '10r = 1 '09r). i hope this kind of explains it! again, you're not wrong at all, it's just the 2:1 rule seems more common :)

[FriedApplePie]

Thank you for help with the previous trades! I got another

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99497711&userid=44211&signature=UFH1fzVvW2Fqbarm3OO7KA

[meged321]

Hi, is this fair? Thank you in advance for any help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99503678&userid=667686&signature=5HlnLI5y3aE3CedUB5sMiA