The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Damocles]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99279380&userid=346461&signature=Z3de22oEx9l3vbQzQBNkKg

Is this fair? Not too sure on the worth of these items

[Victor Grantz.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99278882&userid=968871&signature=X0a60C612sV95-sYafBaLw

Fair?

[aliceeinwonderland]

I really need a fast reply

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99279932&userid=1036393&signature=n8twPtI2aU1mR-_tG3l7Pw

[ferretjuice]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99276412&userid=327768&signature=7eMOzbFBQ5XRHynnZXOU-w
i know they’re both 1.5 nons, any opinions on which pet is better to trade off in the long run?

[PlagueNBlight]

Help with this bid please? ^^

Edit! this too please <3 They edited their bid, but I'm still curious! ^^
this is the edited trade I'm not the biggest fan, I'll admit, but I would like to know if it's fair? ^^

[Sternenfeuer]

Good morning 😊 may Iask for some help with this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99280508&userid=118289&signature=FME0flFukli6IWLocyt1IA

It seems sadly unfair to me, but I'm not too good with rarities. What needs to be done on their side to make this a fair trade?

Thank you so much in advance!

[Sternenfeuer]

Oh, and as well I'd like some help with this one.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99280531&userid=118289&signature=aJNy7OpOxl8gzIZh3fZXUg

How much are my pets worth here?

[SilverDreams7]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99280636&userid=615666&signature=LGRMZEr0biJldgOGXsnoig
Not sure if this is fair, or overpay. I'm not familiar with trading store pets for non store pets.

[sapphirelion]

I really need a fast reply

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99279932&userid=1036393&signature=n8twPtI2aU1mR-_tG3l7Pw

Based only on rarities and when the pets released (your rare is from the 2013 slumber party event), the trade is unfair to your trade partner. However, many pets from the slumber party event have high demand so I would get a second opinion from someone who knows the demand of your pet before making decisions on this trade!

Good morning 😊 may Iask for some help with this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99280508&userid=118289&signature=FME0flFukli6IWLocyt1IA

It seems sadly unfair to me, but I'm not too good with rarities. What needs to be done on their side to make this a fair trade?

Thank you so much in advance!

It is very unfair to you! Using the 2:1 rule on year and rarity differences: The rare bunny can cover one of your 2011 uncommons, while the rest of their side is only worth less than half of a 2014 common (so about the 2014 very common would cover that).

Oh, and as well I'd like some help with this one.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99280531&userid=118289&signature=aJNy7OpOxl8gzIZh3fZXUg

How much are my pets worth here?

Again this trade is very unfair to you. 2021 store pets (their side) are only worth about a mid (May-August) 2010 rare each. If your 2009 Rare was not the birthday shima luan fox, then just that would be fair, but I believe that Fox may be worth a bit more than just a 2009 rare. (Not 100% sure on the fox’s worth, so definitely get another opinion!)

[Jacklin009]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99280896&userid=70184&signature=LPXEeQEL5p5I5dqUDe2dVA

So I feel that this is unfair on my end with the older pets, but not sure about demand for the pets that the other person is trading. What do you all think? Is it somewhat fair if demand is considered? Thanks for the help.