The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Damocles]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252162&userid=346461&signature=_1de_ThDYkKQqY1cNa5MCw

Would this be better? I don’t value higher or lower based on date so I do value td purple toxic at .5 but I’m not good at adding up their side, I know my side is 1.5. Does the rest of their side aside from toxic add up to 1 non?

[nicole]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252162&userid=346461&signature=_1de_ThDYkKQqY1cNa5MCw

Would this be better? I don’t value higher or lower based on date so I do value td purple toxic at .5 but I’m not good at adding up their side, I know my side is 1.5. Does the rest of their side aside from toxic add up to 1 non?

It’s not a TD purple toxic as pets also got rereleased on Dec 18th of 2008. December isn’t the original month of the toxics. It’s still not fair to you with all of the added stuff

[Bridgy1234]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99245592&userid=346461&signature=RbCM1TPUCrjPUxHeiGfNSA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99248547&userid=346461&signature=NoNxCmRxc8GztvXQnjCa_Q

Opinions on these?

trade one:
top:
skelleton pps=high sep[low main / 0.25 non / 3-4 MA]=23-37 09 rares
purple toxic=sorbet teir[0.5 non]=50-75 09 rares
red x pps=high sep[low main / 0.25 non / 3-4 MA]=23-37 09 rares
4 2018 rares=not much
2017 store+1 late 09 rare

total=97-150 09 rares

bottom:
ur Fox=bangle tier[~1.5 non]=150-225 09 rares

so I would personally say no to this trade. it would be just fair if their side were being valued at top dollar and your fox was at its lowest.
info on the list pets came from horrors list



trade two, at a glance I think it maybe fair, if not it is overpay for the items.


edit since you updated the trade

I still wouldn't take it. Personally I would value your fox in the mid-high range. with what was added they are still on the low side, even valuing their lists on their high ends.

[SILVERSOCIO]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99236638&userid=675965&signature=axHYzeAT329U6HDi0IDmwQ

Hello just want a second opinion to make sure this is fair, thank you in advanced!!<3

Still need help please

Please help <3<3<3

[Damocles]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252162&userid=346461&signature=_1de_ThDYkKQqY1cNa5MCw

Would this be better? I don’t value higher or lower based on date so I do value td purple toxic at .5 but I’m not good at adding up their side, I know my side is 1.5. Does the rest of their side aside from toxic add up to 1 non?

It’s not a TD purple toxic as pets also got rereleased on Dec 18th of 2008. December isn’t the original month of the toxics. It’s still not fair to you with all of the added stuff

Oh wow thank you! I would not have realized that, they’re trying to trade it as a true date at .75 nons

[Cady55again]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252407&userid=973739&signature=sXDj3lsZm6Zt9aNta-JbBA

Is this fair? ^^

[sakamoto]

I'm not really looking for items for rare pets but I was curious about a second opinion on this trade :o

[Vully-the-vulpix]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252407&userid=973739&signature=sXDj3lsZm6Zt9aNta-JbBA

Is this fair? ^^

No
Most of the pets are younger than yours and none of them are rares
In addition yours is a store pet

[Cady55again]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252522&userid=973739&signature=niqB_r1efwQlDxWTQn66Mw is this fair??

[Winter Wish]

Does someone mind helping me with this trade? Thank you in advance!

Even though the rarities and dates match up [using 2;1], I'd consider this unfair to you. You have a lion + dog on their side, ande they just have better demand than the pets on your side.

Could I have another opinion on this? Thank you in advance!