The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lex.]

I was wondering if this trade was fair?
Thank you in advance to anyone who replies! <3
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99249603&userid=932703&signature=zW0NEkNUzuuXZQHFBdV2ug

Using the 2;1 ratio, is this fair!

[Bridgy1234]

Could I have some help with this trade please as neither my partner nor myself is good at item values (warning big trade)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99231051&userid=1032038&signature=GNhyIjW_U-xfajTmMLlmng[still looking for advice on this one

And would like some help with this as well
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99240145&userid=1032038&signature=oEDWHrdIRx0Y7Zw5DJjhXw
Help still needed

1 - None of the items they want are worth anything significant, so it's up to you if you want to give up your bulk items.

2 - Fair, but rats don't have good demand. I'd decline this trade.

I would like to add. Items are worth an uncommon from there release year. they are also asking for a good amount of items that are always available and, like all free item sets, are a one time adopt. those items value depends on who you ask, some value them at nothing since in theory there is a set for every account made, I would say a recent uncommon would be a fair value to give them.
Im pretty sure this is a fair trade regardless.

trade two they are overpaying based on date and rarity, but like said before, rats dont have great demand and neither do horses. It is normally very difficult to trade them for most other species, especially cats and dogs

[aliceeinwonderland]

I believe it’s fair but, I’m not 100% on it

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252052&userid=1036393&signature=d2hyVAvI2Jtu1Cq2a1H_hA

[FriedApplePie]

I’m pretty sure it’s fair but I’m not good at items

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99251697&userid=44211&signature=0NVAxwc7SgAeU0FUeyoehg

[citielights]

i don’t know a thing about item rarity- is this fair?

[Bridgy1234]

I believe it’s fair but, I’m not 100% on it

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99252052&userid=1036393&signature=d2hyVAvI2Jtu1Cq2a1H_hA

unfair actually. 2021 stores are worth a late 2010 rare
a 2022 store would be worth an early 2011 rare

I’m pretty sure it’s fair but I’m not good at items

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99251697&userid=44211&signature=0NVAxwc7SgAeU0FUeyoehg

items are worth an uncommon from their release year. I believe these are all from the same years/events. So it would be fair.

[nicole]

i don’t know a thing about item rarity- is this fair?

Very unfair to you. Some of your items are worth an 09 rare each.

[Damocles]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99245592&userid=346461&signature=RbCM1TPUCrjPUxHeiGfNSA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99248547&userid=346461&signature=NoNxCmRxc8GztvXQnjCa_Q

Opinions on these?

[Hiraeth.]

I’m pretty sure it’s fair but I’m not good at items

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99251697&userid=44211&signature=0NVAxwc7SgAeU0FUeyoehg

This is a fair trade, the bunnysaurus costumes are a direct swap and the rest of the items on both sides are from the 2013 slumber party event, none of them have any particular demand and could go for a 1:1 swap

[nicole]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99245592&userid=346461&signature=RbCM1TPUCrjPUxHeiGfNSA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99248547&userid=346461&signature=NoNxCmRxc8GztvXQnjCa_Q

Opinions on these?

I’m going to comment on the first trade as it’s unfair to you. RR Purple toxic is .5n, rr red x pps is .25n and rr skeleton pps is .25n, so in total it’s 1n. Your side is a solid 1.5n. It’s unfair.