The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SeaCrest]

Before I accept, neither of these has any particular demand over the other, correct?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98795003&userid=5378&signature=uOzpVjwDOCLUYxMwpRXNiw

[winx]

Before I accept, neither of these has any particular demand over the other, correct?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98795003&userid=5378&signature=uOzpVjwDOCLUYxMwpRXNiw

Nope! This is a good swap rarity-wise and demand-wise in my opinion.
Dark Tess Dragon - First rarity: UC | 4.11 UC to R | 1.19 R to VR
Candy Cane Tess Dragon - First rarity: UC | 8.11 UC to R | 1.19 R to VR
They even both turned very rare in the January 2019 update, so they’d be fair swaps for each other.

[lucifer morningstar]

could I get some input on this trade? any help is appreciated. c:

[-Frost-]

I'm not great at knowing the worth of VRs, would this be a fair trade for my bw vr?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98786761&userid=182725&signature=bJfOuD-cx0uQP8-nUmATag

[winx]

I'm not great at knowing the worth of VRs, would this be a fair trade for my bw vr?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98786761&userid=182725&signature=bJfOuD-cx0uQP8-nUmATag

You have the “Bee Bwolf” on your side of the trade. It is on the Low October tier of Horror’s list. Based on the tier, it is worth 3 09 rares.
They are offering 2 09 rares, a 2010 uncommon, and a 2011 rare.
2010 unc = 0.5 2009 unc = 0.25 2009 rare.
2011 rare = 0.5 2010 rare = 0.25 2009 rare.
This essentially means they are offering 2.5 09 rares, which is slightly unfair to you by 0.5 09 rare.
I couldn’t find any trade data on it, so I’d recommend getting a second opinion just to be sure.

[Alaskabound]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98795821&userid=322053&signature=z8thdUprVZK_EGNpuGfZqQ

Would this be a fair trade?

They are also offering this alternative trade: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98792751&userid=322053&signature=uuS6UD5e2UgNmv94lkeWiA

Is either of these trades fair? Which would be the more desirable trade? I don't really know the value of list pets.

Thank you in advance.

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98795821&userid=322053&signature=z8thdUprVZK_EGNpuGfZqQ

Would this be a fair trade?

They are also offering this alternative trade: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98792751&userid=322053&signature=uuS6UD5e2UgNmv94lkeWiA

Is either of these trades fair? Which would be the more desirable trade? I don't really know the value of list pets.

Thank you in advance.

For the first trade, your trade partner is massively overpaying.
Your VR warrior cat is worth 1 MA. Each of their rare warrior cats is worth 0.5 MA due to demand. They are offering 10 rare warrior cats, which is 0.5 * 10 = 5 MA in comparison to your 1 MA.

For the second trade, card dogs are typically worth 0.5 MA. They can reach 1 MA as a true date, which isn’t the case here. Two card dogs at 0.5 MA each is 1 MA, while your VR warrior cat is also worth 1 MA. This is a much fairer trade for your trade partner than the first trade.

[☽Lil~Punk~Girl☾]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98772634&userid=624150&signature=2p2trJj3Npw7Eu8aMn74Mw

Is this fair? I'm not sure on item worth, thank you in advance! ♡

Could I get a second opinion on this? Thank you so much ♡

[SeaCrest]

Pretty sure this is unfair to me, but would like confirmation!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98767340&userid=5378&signature=b89BpD0YXNFRgDC1oN6fpA

[lawyer]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98795821&userid=322053&signature=z8thdUprVZK_EGNpuGfZqQ

Would this be a fair trade?

They are also offering this alternative trade: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98792751&userid=322053&signature=uuS6UD5e2UgNmv94lkeWiA

Is either of these trades fair? Which would be the more desirable trade? I don't really know the value of list pets.

Thank you in advance.

For the first trade, your trade partner is massively overpaying.
Your VR warrior cat is worth 1 MA. Each of their rare warrior cats is worth 0.5 MA due to demand. They are offering 10 rare warrior cats, which is 0.5 * 10 = 5 MA in comparison to your 1 MA.

For the second trade, card dogs are typically worth 0.5 MA. They can reach 1 MA as a true date, which isn’t the case here. Two card dogs at 0.5 MA each is 1 MA, while your VR warrior cat is also worth 1 MA. This is a much fairer trade for your trade partner than the first trade.

thank you so much for helping my trading partner! i'm on the other side of the trade. about the first offer, it's for the reason my trading partner can pick 2 warriors there and not the entire set haha. that's why i sent it as a suggestion, i appreciate your input!