The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98679772&userid=270579&signature=Y_8bw7qczbIRpZEo_OQVoA
Can someone help me

Starry Owl PPS - [likely up to ~~1 MAish, but little data]
[1 Mid Advent] = 6-9 09 Rares ------ 250-300C$ (Probably closer to 250 due to the varied rarity of this pet)
C$ trade data, from 2021 and 2020 (so a bit old), shows 130 and 150 C$ trades x. Probably doesn’t directly trade for 1 MA unless a true date, but 50 C$ is definitely not it.
Very unfair to you.

[JayJay]

Is this fair for my black advent? Thank you in advance!

Or is this trade better?

[mikuscreations]

What do you guys think of this ??

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98680170&userid=571194&signature=49n_xZ-049yVgvQDqDSisg

[Lorde.]

hi would this be a good trade? its for my trade partners yellow toxic ! x

[nazzie]

Any help with this trade is appreciated! I feel like it’s fair but the quantity of items they’re asking for seems like a lot in comparison to the amount of pets and rarity of the pets I’m receiving. All pets offered are wishlist for me.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98677642&userid=292169&signature=F_YS5jv6nhD85dReCsFkLA

[abbie.]

any opinions on this trade?

thank you in advance, have a great day!

[Sauron]

Please help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98680858&userid=813877&signature=XiJMTwvMvqfGbZOzAluyBA

[Pastel-Axle]

We've been hearing differing opinions on the value of the pets involved in this trade. Seeking further opinions, please:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98677510&userid=5378&signature=eanZdhdkm4SPUwAxpIYA7w

I'm not terribly invested in the C$; is there an easy pet equivalent?

Bumping this up as well! We’re particularly confused about the manticore; does it trade for 2 ‘09 rares like other ‘15 stores or 0.5 MAs like one person said in this thread before. For both sides, is there any trade evidence (preferably from multiple users) to support this?

[joop]

i know this is fair, both 0.5n, but which would i be better off keeping? demand wise?
either way, very tempting xx

[Lorde.]

hi would this be a good trade? its for my trade partners green toxic ! x

please help c:!