The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Dreams of Roses]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98672679&userid=994917&signature=dg7crd84A8kgxf_cCwKVsw

i recently answered another user trading the peacock PPS / peaPS
by purely rarity, it's worth 2 09 rares, but with PPS pup demand, i think it could go for 3 09's or possibly 0.5 MA
your partner is offering 4 2010 rares which is 2 09 rares. not sure how much value the fae malk fox adds
i think you could get better offers for it.

[JayJay]

Hello would anyone be able to help me with this trade? I count about 2.5non on the bulk side and wanted to see if I can get any opinions on if this is fair or not. Thank you in advance!

[Smokeyman4ever!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98672679&userid=994917&signature=dg7crd84A8kgxf_cCwKVsw

i recently answered another user trading the peacock PPS / peaPS
by purely rarity, it's worth 2 09 rares, but with PPS pup demand, i think it could go for 3 09's or possibly 0.5 MA
your partner is offering 4 2010 rares which is 2 09 rares. not sure how much value the fae malk fox adds
i think you could get better offers for it.

Thank you

[Pastel-Axle]

Can I please get an opinion on this trade before I accept? Is this fair to my end?

their side: 5.5-8 09 rares
lava/fire dragoncat = 0.5 MA
manticore lions may get overpay and could be valued between 2 09 rares and 0.5 MA

Your side: 7 09 rares
zodiac dogs are usually valued at 2-3 09 rares or 0.5 MA (closer to 3.5 09 rares) as a rerelease, i'd value yours at 3.
2017 store pets are said to be worth a mid 09 rare each
the other pets add up to 2 09 rares each

Would I be better off accepting this or holding onto my pets? 5.5-8 ‘09 rares is quite a large range of values ;v;

[240SX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98676061&userid=536230&signature=aRMgMfjNyY2N8YPzrsf2Jw

We were both wondering if this is fair, both of us don't know the rarities on these plushes. Any help would be appreciated!

[winx]

Hello would anyone be able to help me with this trade? I count about 2.5non on the bulk side and wanted to see if I can get any opinions on if this is fair or not. Thank you in advance!

Their side:
Patchwork - ~1.5 nons (most consistently valued here, may be valued up to 2 nons) -x

Your side:
Light Leopard - 2 MA
Scarf PPS - ~2 MA, seems like true dates can reach ~3 MA, which is right around 0.25 nons
Blue Scarf Dog - 0.5 MA, has gone up up to 1 MA for a true date
White Scarf Dog - 0.5 MA, has gone up to 1 MA for a true date
Peppermint Ear Advent - 1 MA most commonly, has gone up to 2 MA for a true date
Sockdog - likely ~2ish MA, but little data
Mustard Heart Husky - 1 MA
Snowflake Advent - 1 MA
Purple Heart Husky - 1 MA
Hollyfox Dog - 0.25 nons
Pink Punk - 0.5 nons
Totals:
I'm going to use the higher values I found for true dates if I found trade data that showed that a particular pet trades more if they're TD. I believe most of the Mid Advents could probably reach 2 MA if they're true date, but if I didn't find trade data that reflected that, then I did not list it.
2 + 1 + 1 + 2 + 2 + 1 + 1 + 1 = ~11 MA
0.25 + 0.25 + 0.5 = 1 non
0.5 NON / 1 SORB = 5-7 MA... which means it's around ~2 nons on your side. 2.5 nons is possible when valuing the remaining true date Mid Advents as 2 MA.
Either way, this trade is unfair to your side.

[abbie.]

any opinions on this trade?

also, would the ice fairy rat store pet from 2013 be a fair swap for the dark eyed GSD dog?
as far as i'm aware both are worth one mid-advent but i was also wondering about demand and if one would have to add?

thank you in advance if you can help with either one, have a great day!

[JayJay]

Hello would anyone be able to help me with this trade? I count about 2.5non on the bulk side and wanted to see if I can get any opinions on if this is fair or not. Thank you in advance!

Their side:
Patchwork - ~1.5 nons (most consistently valued here, may be valued up to 2 nons) -x

Your side:
Light Leopard - 2 MA
Scarf PPS - ~2 MA, seems like true dates can reach ~3 MA, which is right around 0.25 nons
Blue Scarf Dog - 0.5 MA, has gone up up to 1 MA for a true date
White Scarf Dog - 0.5 MA, has gone up to 1 MA for a true date
Peppermint Ear Advent - 1 MA most commonly, has gone up to 2 MA for a true date
Sockdog - likely ~2ish MA, but little data
Mustard Heart Husky - 1 MA
Snowflake Advent - 1 MA
Purple Heart Husky - 1 MA
Hollyfox Dog - 0.25 nons
Pink Punk - 0.5 nons
Totals:
I'm going to use the higher values I found for true dates if I found trade data that showed that a particular pet trades more if they're TD. I believe most of the Mid Advents could probably reach 2 MA if they're true date, but if I didn't find trade data that reflected that, then I did not list it.
2 + 1 + 1 + 2 + 2 + 1 + 1 + 1 = ~11 MA
0.25 + 0.25 + 0.5 = 1 non
0.5 NON / 1 SORB = 5-7 MA... which means it's around ~2 nons on your side. 2.5 nons is possible when valuing the remaining true date Mid Advents as 2 MA.
Either way, this trade is unfair to your side.

Thank you so much for your help!

[Pastel-Axle]

Can I please get an opinion on this trade before I accept? Is this fair to my end?

their side: 5.5-8 09 rares
lava/fire dragoncat = 0.5 MA
manticore lions may get overpay and could be valued between 2 09 rares and 0.5 MA

Your side: 7 09 rares
zodiac dogs are usually valued at 2-3 09 rares or 0.5 MA (closer to 3.5 09 rares) as a rerelease, i'd value yours at 3.
2017 store pets are said to be worth a mid 09 rare each
the other pets add up to 2 09 rares each

Would I be better off accepting this or holding onto my pets? 5.5-8 ‘09 rares is quite a large range of values ;v;

[abbie.]

any opinions on this trade?

also, would the ice fairy rat store pet from 2013 be a fair swap for the dark eyed GSD dog?
as far as i'm aware both are worth one mid-advent but i was also wondering about demand and if one would have to add?

thank you in advance if you can help with either one, have a great day!