The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98551925&userid=714665&signature=w0xXHz83FvtjY6wSgNoNbw
looking for some help with this one ^^

bumping as trading partner

up

Cloudstar warrior cat --> rare warrior cats have been trading for around 0.5 MA due to demand -x
Purple Alien Dog --> 1 MA - x
April Fool's UR Butterdog --> 1 MA - x
2013 rare --> 3 month rule
Lava Kirin/Koi Store Dog, Orange Kirin/Koi Dog --> 0.5 MA each to equal 1 MA - x
Cherry Blossom/Sakura Dog --> ~1 MA - x x
Blue Snowflake Scarf Dog (Low October) --> ~0.5 MA - x
2021 uncommon --> 3 month rule
Floppy Green Pastel --> 3 month rule or 2 09 rares + 1 '10 rare, grabbed that value from here since there is practically no data on it
Dog Santa Hat --> 1 LA which is about 0.5-0.75 MA - x x
Checked other guides as well to find more on the Dog Santa Hat, but couldn't find a lot to backup the 1 LA value... so I will keep it there loosely. If someone has a better idea on this, please post!
0.5 MA (WC) + 1 MA (alien store) + 1 MA (butterdog) + 1 MA (both koi dogs) + 1 MA (sakura store) + 0.5 MA (scarf dog) + 0.5/0.75 MA (santa hat) =
5.5/5.75 MA + (2 09 rares + 1 '10 rare (green pastel)) + 1 2013 rare + 1 2021 uncommon

PPS Dragoncat: ~0.25+ nons or ~3-4+ MAs - x

Considering 0.25 nons is 3-4 MA, it seems like it is fair purely based on trade data alone (cannot speak for any particular demand on the bulk side). As for demand, that is a different story. This would be a trade down for the Dragoncat side. I personally would not accept simply because it might be difficult to trade off the other pets in comparison to the Dragoncat.
The PPS Dragoncat has //huge// demand, so it is up to you and your trade partner if you feel this is a good trade or not.
Definitely recommend getting a second opinion as well.

[ferretjuice]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98572023&userid=327768&signature=R8ty43eJTrAp4hIZ6q3bQA
is this trade good? <3

any thoughts?

[winx]

Thoughts? Last time I checked a 2016 store was going for a 2009 rare but I’m not sure what that translates to on C$. Thanks!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98536375&userid=42960&signature=w8GwNa6kNppIaS2DyRNS-Q

2016 store pet valued at ~1 early '09 rare. Recently been trading for 1-2 '09 rares. - x
One successful C$ trade of a littermate of this store pet for 85 C$ --> x *would like to add this trade was from 2020, so it is a bit older*
Using the C$ guide here, an '09 rare/vr is between 35-55 C$ (ballpark estimate). I usually split this value in half, so the first half is for rares and the second for very rares. '09 rare is then between 35-45. Valuing the 2016 flying dog at 2 '09 rares based on recent data means the C$ value should fall between 35 + 35 and 45 + 45 = 70-90.
The value they offered does fall in this range, but you could potentially get a bit more based on the successful C$ trade above for 85 C$. Ultimately, it is up to you! (:

[FleshCanvas]

I haven't been on CS for awhile I need help kinda ^^; trades/viewtrade.php?id=98566604&userid=695200&signature=a4APchI3zjrhJHn8gxeQ_A

would still like help on this thanks

[winx]

I haven't been on CS for awhile I need help kinda ^^; trades/viewtrade.php?id=98566604&userid=695200&signature=a4APchI3zjrhJHn8gxeQ_A

would still like help on this thanks

They’re offering:
2021 store pet valued at ~1 late '10 rare —> 0.5 late 2009 rare using 2:1 rule
2 early to mid 2010 rares —> 1 early to mid 2009 rare using 2:1 rule
Other pets don’t affect outcome
Total: ~1.5 ‘09 rares

Your side:
2017 store pet valued at ~1 mid '09 rare.

Fair by technicality, but I personally wouldn’t take it since the fennecs have good demand. (: None of the pets on their side have any particular demand in comparison.
Please get a second opinion too since everyone has a different perspective on demand.

[Pastel-Axle]

I haven't been on CS for awhile I need help kinda ^^; trades/viewtrade.php?id=98566604&userid=695200&signature=a4APchI3zjrhJHn8gxeQ_A

They’re offering:
2021 store pet valued at ~1 late '10 rare —> 0.5 late 2009 rare using 2:1 rule
2 early to mid 2010 rares —> 1 early to mid 2009 rare using 2:1 rule
Other pets don’t affect outcome
Total: ~1.5 ‘09 rares

Your side:
2017 store pet valued at ~1 mid '09 rare.

Fair by technicality, but I personally wouldn’t take it since the fennecs have good demand. (: None of the pets on their side have any particular demand in comparison.
Please get a second opinion too since everyone has a different perspective on demand.

This is only my personal experience, but though the fennecs are fairly well liked I haven’t seen any evidence that they trade above the standard ‘17 store value of a mid ‘09 rare, at least not when I’ve traded with them.

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98574528&userid=813059&signature=8c6SjriQDUG575NSEeKXsw is this fair?

Bumping this up for my trade partner. Is this fair to the both of us? If not, what would need to be changed?

[-Starfox-]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98574979&userid=341698&signature=SJzfMYhS0ZAtv-hkBJGo5A

I’m looking for opinions here, any help is very much welcomed!

[Silki]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98574987&userid=481898&signature=KI1wCvDopZRlKoB4N_uqyg

havent been on in a while, is this fair?

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98574987&userid=481898&signature=KI1wCvDopZRlKoB4N_uqyg

havent been on in a while, is this fair?

Zodiacs most commonly go for around 2-3 ‘09 rares worth, so this is a fair trade. It just depends on what you prefer - if you’re looking to trade these pets off, you’d probably be better off with the Zodiac as they’re always fairly popular. Please get a second opinion!