The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98571746&userid=669255&signature=ED3XxG2Q7dUojywa6xJDIA

please help!! Im not sure of the demand of the OMGSR PPS dog.. opinions???

Their side:
July PPS consistently trades for 1 non, but it can be difficult to trade due to its bad demand.
Total: 1 non

Your side:
There's two Line Tribals in the trade. Line Tribals also have bad demand. They consistently trade for 0.25 non. 0.25 non + 0.25 non = 0.5 non.
Light Brown Cake Dog has neutral demand. They pretty consistently get 2 MA.
Dark Leopard has neutral demand. Consistently gets 2 MA.
Light Leopard has good demand. Consistently gets 2 MA and up to 0.25 non for a TD.
Totals: 0.5 non + 2 MA + 2 MA + 2 MA --> 0.5 non + 6 MA
[0.5 NON / 1 SORB] = 5-7 MA
~1 non

Decently fair in my opinion, but the July PPS in general is going to be difficult to trade off. They included one pet that has decently good demand (Light Leopard) which makes me question if you could get something better in the long run. I would not personally take this trade.
I would get a second opinion on this one due to the demand disparities. edit; drown gave a great first opinion, haha. it is truly up to you!

edit;; was late again on posting. oop. and apologies on an earlier post, accidentally wrote vixen instead of holly oop. thank you for catching that! @HazelNightmare

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98571746&userid=669255&signature=ED3XxG2Q7dUojywa6xJDIA

please help!! Im not sure of the demand of the OMGSR PPS dog.. opinions???

To start, their dog (the July PPS) trades consistently for 1 non, and doesn’t have the best demand.
Your side is as follows:
2x Line Tribals = 0.5n (0.25n each)
Leopard dogs = ~4MAs (2MAs each)
Cake dog = 2MAs (all cake dogs seem to swap evenly from what I’ve seen?)
Therefore, your side adds up to around 11-13 MAs, equating to around 1 non (or just over a non if you value the tribals at their highest value, though given their low demand I’d advise against that).
Thus, this trade is up to your preference. Neither your pets or your partner’s experience much demand, so it comes down to whether you want quality or quantity.
Please get a second opinion on this matter!
EDIT: Apparently the light leopard has some demand? I was not aware of this, apologies. Regardless, my opinion on the trade still stands. The July PPS’ demand isn’t great, so trading it off for its worth could be difficult.

[joop]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98551925&userid=714665&signature=w0xXHz83FvtjY6wSgNoNbw
looking for some help with this one ^^

bumping as trading partner

up

[Lain of the wired]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98574528&userid=813059&signature=8c6SjriQDUG575NSEeKXsw is this fair?

[ferretjuice]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98572023&userid=327768&signature=R8ty43eJTrAp4hIZ6q3bQA
is this trade good? <3

[valkyrie,,]

hello! i have two trades i'd like some help on. trade 1; '16 store pet for '09 lion. trade 2; july pps. thank you!!

[Rbpuppy]

Thoughts? Last time I checked a 2016 store was going for a 2009 rare but I’m not sure what that translates to on C$. Thanks!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98536375&userid=42960&signature=w8GwNa6kNppIaS2DyRNS-Q

[Paradime]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98568215&userid=130089&signature=St94_T-sDM9uwYSTn1IvkA

What do you guys think of this trade? Since the change in the rares guide, I've not quite been able to price out these higher OMG so rares (or find the new guide people are following).

Any help is appreciated! Thank you =)

[Pastel-Axle]

hello! i have two trades i'd like some help on. trade 1; '16 store pet for '09 lion. trade 2; july pps. thank you!!

For trade 1, it appears that the other end is overpaying. While lions tend to have good demand, so too does the raptor store pet. ‘16 stores are worth an early ‘09 rare without demand involved, so by that account they are already overpaying. The raptor in particular has volatile demand, while I have traded some away and traded for them for fair swaps, other times I have been offered overpay due to the design’s popularity. It depends on the trader, but I personally see the ‘16 store as overpay, based on both dates and demand.

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98574528&userid=813059&signature=8c6SjriQDUG575NSEeKXsw is this fair?

Bumping this up for my trade partner. Is this fair to the both of us? If not, what would need to be changed?