The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ToastQueen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98573680&userid=127596&signature=VE0XZM_BMwHTdX5FBtaF2A

I'm not great with valuing, but this feels a bit unfair to me. I'd really like a second opinion before I just cancel while admitting that

[lamplighterB612]

Is this fair?
Please help ASAP!

[outera]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98572082&userid=942786&signature=IeBVUIbZtXGESgZVCGfqXg
thank u in advance to anyone who helps!

[Aktori]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98544806&userid=737315&signature=W9JRUN0Ey2gh48P0jZrlyQ

Is this fair?

[drown]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98544806&userid=737315&signature=W9JRUN0Ey2gh48P0jZrlyQ

Is this fair?

Sunjewel is 3 nons. 1 non goes for 1600-2000 C$.
I'd say it's fair :)

Link for worths + C$ pricing: Horror's Rarity list

[winx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98544806&userid=737315&signature=W9JRUN0Ey2gh48P0jZrlyQ

Is this fair?

Here is the most recent Sunjewel C$ trade data: x
The three most recent (all taking place in 2021) were 5000-6000 C$ (more towards 6000+ range).
Additionally, on the successful trade thread, it seems, as of 2022, it goes consistently for 3 nons. Sometimes up to 3.5 nons as well.
On Horror's list...
[3-3.5 NONS] = [~~6000-8000C$].
Based on the values I found, I would say it is fair.

edit; didn't see drown's post! seconding their opinion. <3

[winx]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98572082&userid=942786&signature=IeBVUIbZtXGESgZVCGfqXg
thank u in advance to anyone who helps!

Hollyfox Dog is a Mid Advent on Horror's list. 2 MA to 0.25 nons - x

Their side has the Brown Border Collie. It is also a Mid Advent on Horror's list. It usually reaches ~1 MA or 6-9 09 rares. A true date can reach 1.5 MA - x.
I personally believe this trade is unfair to you because the Hollyfox has much higher demand. It can consistently reach values of 2 MA or higher, while the Brown Border Collie only reaches 1.5 MA at its most.

edit; correcting me accidentally putting vixen instead of holly oop

[xxgalaxylightxx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98571746&userid=669255&signature=ED3XxG2Q7dUojywa6xJDIA

please help!! Im not sure of the demand of the OMGSR PPS dog.. opinions???

[♥HazelNightmare]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98573680&userid=127596&signature=VE0XZM_BMwHTdX5FBtaF2A

I'm not great with valuing, but this feels a bit unfair to me. I'd really like a second opinion before I just cancel while admitting that

2011 uncommons are usually valued at 9-10c$ , so it would be 54-60 c$ , so their under a bit .
This thread can help you with C$ values Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3915876

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98572082&userid=942786&signature=IeBVUIbZtXGESgZVCGfqXg
thank u in advance to anyone who helps!

Vixen Advent is a Mid Advent on Horror's list. On Horror's list, it is quoted as being worth ~1-2 MA - x True dates can reach 3 MA to 0.25 nons (3-4 MA). Usually reaches towards the 2 MA range due to its popularity and demand.
1 MA is worth: 6-9 09 rares
1.5-2 MA is worth: 12-16 09 rares
Their side has the Brown Border Collie. It is also a Mid Advent on Horror's list. It usually reaches ~1 MA or 6-9 09 rares. A true date can reach 1.5 MA - x.
I personally believe this trade is unfair to you because the Vixen has much higher demand. It can consistently reach values of 2 MA, while the Brown Border Collie only reaches 1.5 MA at its most.

My other response got deleted not sure if it was on my end.

I agree with values but it’s the HollyFox not Vixen, the HollyFox has really good demand and definitely goes for more then the border collie .
HollyFox min 2 MA up to 3-4 td here
Border collie 1 MA

[drown]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98571746&userid=669255&signature=ED3XxG2Q7dUojywa6xJDIA

please help!! Im not sure of the demand of the OMGSR PPS dog.. opinions???

July PPS: 1 Non

Your side:

2 Line tribals = .25n to .5n each (.5-1n)
Light Brown Cake Dog = 2 MAs
Dark Leopard = 2-3 MAs
Light Leopard = 1.5-2 MAs

At minimum your side is .75 non ( .25n for each line tribal = .5n. ~4.5 MAs = .25n/.5n (.25n is 3-4 MAs, .5n is 5-7 MAs))
At maximum your side is 1.5 non (.5n for each line tribal = 1n. 7 MAs = .5n)

I'd say it's up to you <3 Please check my math on this though!

Link for worths and how I priced this: Horror's List